Complex Lipid Requirements for SNARE- and SNARE Chaperone-dependent Membrane Fusion

Membrane fusion without lysis has been reconstituted with purified yeast vacuolar SNAREs (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors), the SNARE chaperones Sec17p/Sec18p and the multifunctional HOPS complex, which includes a subunit of the SNARE-interactive Sec1-Munc18 family, and vacuolar lipids: phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), phosphatidylinositol (PI), phosphatidylserine (PS), phosphatidic acid (PA), cardiolipin (CL), ergosterol (ERG), diacylglycerol (DAG), and phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate (PI3P). We now report that many of these lipids are required for rapid and efficient fusion of the reconstituted SNARE proteoliposomes in the presence of SNARE chaperones. Omission of either PE, PA, or PI3P from the complete set of lipids strongly reduces fusion, and PC, PE, PA, and PI3P constitute a minimal set of lipids for fusion. PA could neither be replaced by other lipids with small headgroups such as DAG or ERG nor by the acidic lipids PS or PI. PA is needed for full association of HOPS and Sec18p with proteoliposomes having a minimal set of lipids. Strikingly, PA and PE are as essential for SNARE complex assembly as for fusion, suggesting that these lipids facilitate functional interactions among SNAREs and SNARE chaperones.Biological membrane fusion is the regulated rearrangement of the lipids in two apposed sealed membranes to form one bilayer while mixing lumenal contents without leakage or lysis. It is fundamental for intracellular vesicular traffic, cell growth and division, regulated secretion of hormones and other blood proteins, and neurotransmission and thus has attracted wide and sustained study (1, 2). Its fundamental mechanisms are conserved and employ a Rab-family GTPase, proteins which bind to the GTP-bound form of a Rab, termed its “effectors” (3), and SNARE³ (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors) proteins (4) with their attendant chaperones. SNAREs are integral or peripheral membrane proteins with characteristic heptad-repeat domains, which can associate in 4-helical coiled-coils (5), termed “cis-SNARE complexes,” if they are all anchored to the same membrane bilayer, or “trans-SNARE complexes” if they are anchored to apposed membranes.Stable membrane proximity (docking) does not suffice for fusion. Studies in model systems have shown that fusion can be promoted by any of several agents, which promote bilayer rearrangement, such as diacylglycerol (6), high levels of calcium (7), viral-encoded fusion proteins (8, 9), or SNAREs (10, 11). These studies frequently employed liposomes or proteoliposomes of simple lipid composition, suggesting that fusion may not have stringent requirements of lipid head group species. However, each of these model fusion reactions is accompanied by substantial lysis (12–15), whereas the preservation of subcellular compartments is a hallmark of physiological membrane fusion.We have studied membrane fusion with the vacuole (lysosome) of Saccharomyces cerevisiae (reviewed in Ref. 16). The fusion of isolated vacuoles requires the Rab Ypt7p, 4 SNAREs (Vam3p, Vti1p, Vam7p, and Nyv1p), the SNARE chaperones Sec17p (α-soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein)/Sec18p (N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor) and the hexameric HOPS complex (17), and key “regulatory” lipids including ERG, phosphoinositides, and DAG (18). HOPS interacts physically or functionally with each component of this fusion system. HOPS stably associates with Ypt7p in its GTP-bound state (19). One HOPS subunit, Vps33p, is a member of the Sec1-Munc18 family of SNARE-binding proteins, and HOPS exhibits direct affinity for SNAREs (17, 20–22) and proofreads correct vacuolar SNARE pairing (23). HOPS also has direct affinity for phosphoinositides (17). The SNAREs on isolated vacuoles are in cis-complexes, which are disassembled by Sec17p, Sec18p, and ATP (24). Docking requires Ypt7p (25) and HOPS (17). During docking, vacuoles are drawn against each other until each has a substantial membrane domain tightly apposed to the other. Each of the proteins (26) and lipids (18) required for fusion becomes enriched in a ring-shaped microdomain, the “vertex ring,” which surrounds the two tightly apposed membrane domains. Not only do the proteins depend on each other, in a cascade fashion, for vertex ring enrichment, and the lipids depend on each other for their vertex ring enrichment as well, but the lipids and proteins are mutually interdependent for their enrichment at this ring-shaped microdomain (18, 27). Fusion occurs around the ring, joining the two organelles. The fusion of vacuoles bearing physiological fusion constituents does not cause measurable organelle lysis, although fusion supported exclusively by higher levels of SNARE proteins is accompanied by massive lysis (28), in accord with model liposome studies (14). Thus fusion microdomain assembly and the coordinate action of SNAREs with other proteins and lipids to promote fusion without lysis are central topics in membrane fusion studies.Reconstitution of fusion with pure components allows chemical definition of essential elements of this biologically important reaction. Although SNAREs can drive a slow fusion of PC/PS proteoliposomes (29), this was not stimulated by HOPS and Sec17p/Sec18p (30). SNARE proteoliposomes bearing all the vacuolar lipids (18, 31–33), PC, PE, PI, PS, CL, PA, ERG, DAG, PI3P, and phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PI(4,5)P₂), showed rapid and efficient fusion that was fully dependent on Sec17p/Sec18p and HOPS (30). The omission of either DAG, ERG, or phosphoinositide from the liposomes caused a marked reduction in fusion (30). We now report that PE and PA are also necessary for rapid and efficient fusion, function in distinct manners, and are required for efficient assembly of newly formed SNARE complexes by the SNARE chaperones Sec17p/Sec18p and HOPS.