Deciphering Structural and Functional Roles of Individual Disulfide Bonds of the Mitochondrial Sulfhydryl Oxidase Erv1p

Erv1p is a FAD-dependent sulfhydryl oxidase of the mitochondrial intermembrane space. It contains three conserved disulfide bonds arranged in two CXXC motifs and one CX₁₆C motif. Experimental evidence for the specific roles of the individual disulfide bonds is lacking. In this study, structural and functional roles of the disulfides were dissected systematically using a wide range of biochemical and biophysical methods. Three double cysteine mutants with each pair of cysteines mutated to serines were generated. All of the mutants were purified with the normal FAD binding properties as the wild type Erv1p, showing that none of the three disulfides are essential for FAD binding. Thermal denaturation and trypsin digestion studies showed that the CX₁₆C disulfide plays an important role in stabilizing the folding of Erv1p. To understand the functional role of each disulfide, small molecules and the physiological substrate protein Mia40 were used as electron donors in oxygen consumption assays. We show that both CXXC disulfides are required for Erv1 oxidase activity. The active site disulfide is well protected thus requires the shuttle disulfide for its function. Although both mutants of the CXXC motifs were individually inactive, Erv1p activity was partially recovered by mixing these two mutants together, and the recovery was rapid. Thus, we provided the first experimental evidence of electron transfer between the shuttle and active site disulfides of Erv1p, and we propose that both intersubunit and intermolecular electron transfer can occur.Disulfide bonds play very important roles in the structure and function of many proteins by stabilizing protein folding and/or acting as thiol/disulfide redox switches. The process of disulfide formation is catalyzed by dedicated enzymes in vivo (1–4). Erv1p is a FAD-dependent sulfhydryl oxidase located in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mitochondrial intermembrane space (4–6). It is an essential component of the redox regulated Mia40/Erv1 import and assembly pathway used by many of the cysteine-containing intermembrane space proteins, such as members of the “small Tim” and Cox17 families (7–10). Upon import of a Cys-reduced substrate, Mia40 interacts with the substrate via intermolecular disulfide bond and shuttles a disulfide to its substrate. Although oxidized Mia40 promotes disulfide bond formation in the substrates, Erv1p functions in catalyzing reoxidation of the reduced Mia40 and/or release of the substrate (11–13).The common features for the FAD-dependent sulfhydryl oxidases are that the enzymes can catalyze the electron transfer from substrate molecules (e.g. protein thiols) through the noncovalent bound FAD cofactor to molecular oxygen or oxidized cytochrome c (14). The sulfhydryl oxidases can be divided into three groups: Ero1 enzymes, multidomain quiesin sulfhydryl oxidases, and single domain Erv (essential for respiration and vegetative growth)/ALR proteins. The yeast Ero1p and the mammalian homologues (Ero1α and Ero1β) are large flavoenzymes present in the ER with at least five disulfide bonds, but only two of the disulfide bonds are conserved. The conserved cysteines are essential for the catalytic activity of Ero1p forming the active site CXXC and shuttle disulfide CX₄C, respectively (15, 16). Furthermore, nonconserved disulfide bonds have been shown recently to be important in regulating the activity of both yeast and mammalian Ero1 (17–19). The second group of oxidases, the multidomain quiesin sulfhydryl oxidases, have important functions in higher eukaryotes (14, 20). Quiesin sulfhydryl oxidases consist of an Erv/ALR module fused to one or more thioredoxin-like domains with two conserved CXXC motifs in the Erv/ALR module. Quiesin sulfhydryl oxidase enzymes are found in many subcellular and extracellular locations, but not in mitochondria. Instead, single domain Erv/ARL enzymes of the third group are found in the 7mitochondria of many eukaryotic cells (21). Erv1p belongs to this single domain Erv/ARL family, which includes the human mitochondrial ARL, plant AtErv1, and yeast Erv2p of the ER lumen.The Erv/ARL enzymes are characterized by a highly conserved central catalytic core of ∼100 amino acids, which includes an active site CXXC motif (Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³ for Erv1p), CX₁₆C disulfide bond (Cys¹⁵⁹–Cys¹⁷⁶ for Erv1p), and residues involved in FAD binding (Fig. 1A). Based on the partial crystal structure data of Erv2p (22) and AtErv1 (23), the catalytic core of Erv proteins contains a four-helix bundle forming the noncovalent FAD-binding site with the active site CXXC in close proximity to the isoalloxazine ring of FAD. In addition, the long range CX₁₆C disulfide bond of the Erv proteins brings the short fifth helix to the four-helix bundle in proximity to the adenine ring of FAD (Fig. 1A). Thus, the CX₁₆C disulfide bond is proposed to play a structural role in stabilizing the FAD binding and/or protein folding, but direct experimental evidence to verify the roles is lacking. Apart from the catalytic core, the other parts of the proteins seem flexible and unfolded. Importantly, all members of the Erv/ALR family have at least an additional disulfide bond located in the nonconserved N- or C-terminal region to the catalytic core (Fig. 1B), which is hypothesized as a shuttle disulfide based on the partial crystal structure of Erv2 (22). The hypothesized shuttle disulfide of Erv2p CXC and AtErv1 CX₄C are located in the C terminus, but Erv1p (Cys³⁰–Cys³³) and ALR have a CXXC shuttle disulfide located N-terminal to the catalytic core. Furthermore, structural and chemical data have suggested that Erv/ARL enzymes form homodimer or oligomers in the presence or absence of intermolecular disulfide bonds (5, 23, 24).Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.Structure and conserved Cys motifs of Erv/ALR enzymes. A, modeled structures of the conserved central catalytic core domain of Erv1p dimer based on the crystal structure data of AtErv1 (Protein Data Bank accession number 2HJ3, residues 73–173, the helix 1 starts with residue 75). The helices of the four-helix bundle and the short fifth helix are labeled from 1 to 5. The two disulfides are shown as yellow spheres, and the cofactor FAD is in red. The Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³ is the redox active disulfide located closely to the isoalloxazine ring of FAD. The N and C termini were labeled as N and C, respectively. The structure was generated using Pymol program. B, schematic of the primary structure of yeast, plant, and human sulfhydryl oxidase with the conserved Cys motifs. The conserved central catalytic core regions are shown as black bars, and the nonconserved regions are in gray.Yeast mitochondrial Erv1p contains a total of six Cys residues forming three pairs of disulfide bonds (residues 30–33, 130–133, and 159–176) as described above. Previous studies with single Cys mutants showed that although all three disulfide bonds are essential for Erv1p function in vivo, only Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³ disulfide is required for the oxidase activity of Erv1p in vitro (24). The conclusion that only Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³ disulfide is required for Erv1p oxidase activity in vitro was based on a study using the artificial substrate DTT² as the electron donor. Abnormal color changes were observed for some of the single Cys mutants of Erv1p in the previous study that were probably caused by protein misfolding or formation of non-native disulfides because of the presence of a redox active but unpaired Cys. It is clear that Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³ is the active site disulfide; however, experimental evidence for the role of Cys³⁰–Cys³³ disulfide is lacking, and the specific role played by the unique CX₁₆C motif of Erv proteins is unknown.In this study, we dissected the structural and functional roles of all three individual disulfides of Erv1p systematically. To avoid misfolding via unpaired Cys, three double Cys mutants of Erv1p were generated with each of the disulfides mutated to serines. All three mutants were successfully purified with the normal FAD binding properties of the wild type (WT) Erv1p. Various biophysical and biochemical methods were used to study the folding and oxidase activity of the WT and Erv1p mutants. Both artificial and the natural substrate (Mia40) of Erv1p were used as electron donors to understand the functional mechanism of Erv1p. Our results show that both the first (Cys³⁰–Cys³³) and second (Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³) disulfides are essential for Erv1 oxidase activity in vitro. Although none of the three disulfides are essential for FAD binding, the third disulfide (Cys¹⁵⁹–Cys¹⁷⁶) plays an important role in stabilizing the folding of Erv1p. More importantly, this study provided direct experimental evidence to show that Cys³⁰–Cys³³ functionally acts as a shuttle disulfide passing electrons to the active site Cys¹³⁰–Cys¹³³ disulfide. Moreover, the electron transfer seems to occur through both intersubunit and intermolecular interactions.