Structural and Inhibition Analysis Reveals the Mechanism of Selectivity of a Series of Aggrecanase Inhibitors

Several inhibitors of a series of cis-1(S)2(R)-amino-2-indanol-based compounds were reported to be selective for the aggrecanases, ADAMTS-4 and -5 over other metalloproteases. To understand the nature of this selectivity for aggrecanases, the inhibitors, along with the broad spectrum metalloprotease inhibitor marimastat, were independently bound to the catalytic domain of ADAMTS-5, and the corresponding crystal structures were determined. By comparing the structures, it was determined that the specificity of the relative inhibitors for ADAMTS-5 was not driven by a specific interaction, such as zinc chelation, hydrogen bonding, or charge interactions, but rather by subtle and indirect factors, such as water bridging, ring rigidity, pocket size, and shape, as well as protein conformation flexibility.Osteoarthritis (OA)³ pathology includes degradation of articular cartilage, along with subchondral bone sclerosis and osteophyte formation, all contributing to impaired joint function. Pain, restricted movement, and joint instability accompany these structural changes and often result in the need for total joint replacement. Current therapies alleviate the mild to moderate pain and inflammation associated with OA, but do not protect the cartilage from further damage and have not demonstrated an effect on disease progression (1). Therefore, therapeutics that prevent or slow the alteration of joint structure and function will address a major unmet medical need.Loss of aggrecan, a macromolecular proteoglycan providing cartilage with its properties of compressibility and resilience, is a major phenotype associated with OA and is believed to be a critical event in driving disease progression (2, 3). Both ex vivo and in vivo proof of concept studies support ADAMTS-4 and ADAMTS-5, commonly referred to as aggrecanase-1 and -2, respectively, as the two major enzymes responsible for the proteolytic breakdown of cartilage aggrecan (reviewed in Ref. 4). Blocking their activity may be an attractive strategy to stop or slow down the progression of the disease, as suggested by studies in knock-out mice (5). Given the chronic nature of the disease, long term treatment will be likely, demanding very safe therapeutic interventions only achievable with ADAMTS-4- and ADAMTS-5-specific inhibitors lacking off-target side effects. Designing selectivity has been very challenging and a major source of difficulty is that at least 57 metalloproteases (MP) divided in three major families, 1) matrix metalloproteases (MMP); 2) a disintegrin and metalloproteinase (ADAM); and 3) a disintegrin and metalloproteinase with thrombospondin motifs (ADAMTS), are present in humans. ADAMTS-4 and -5 belong to the ADAMTS family and share common catalytic and structural features with the other MP members. These features include the highly conserved amino acid sequence, HEXXHXXGXXH, harboring a catalytic zinc cation, required for activation of the peptide bond toward hydrolysis. In addition, many MPs share significant structural topology in the active site, such as a flexible S1′ loop. To complicate matters further, only a handful of MP structures, mostly in the MMP family, have been determined, and the functions of most MPs still remain unknown, a fact that has earned them an orphan status denomination. Lack of structural information has hindered the design for inhibitor specificity and without known substrates for many MPs, assays for screening inhibitors are often not available, making determinations of selectivity difficult (6, 7).Yao et al. (8, 9) reported the discovery of a series of (2R)-N4-hydroxy-2-(3-hydroxybenzyl)-N1-[(1S,2R)-2-hydroxy-,3-dihydro-1H-inden-1-yl]butanediamide derivatives as potent and selective inhibitors of aggrecanase activity. Using a homology model of aggrecanase based on the active site of atrolysin C and adamalysin II and docking compound 8, shown in Fig. 1, the authors concluded that the 3-hydroxyl group of inhibitor 8 achieved selectivity through a specific hydrogen-bonding interaction with Thr⁴⁴⁰ (numerical numbering is based on the human sequence of ADAMTS-5) in the S1′ pocket of aggrecanase.Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.Aggrecanase inhibitors. Structures of the inhibitors evaluated in these studies. The P1 moiety of each inhibitor is marked in red.Whereas both ADAMTS-4 and -5 have a threonine at this position, MMP-1, -2, -3, -7, -8, -9, -10, -13, -14, -16, and ADAM-17 have a valine, lending credence to the proposed hypothesis around selectivity. Recently, our group has established a protocol for crystallizing the catalytic domain of ADAMTS-5 and determined its three-dimensional structure (10). Thus, experimental validation or invalidation of the hypothesis that inhibitor 8 and related molecules form a specific hydrogen bond with the hydroxyl group of threonine in the S1′ pocket of aggrecanases could now be determined by protease-inhibitor crystallographic analysis.In the current study, we wanted to confirm and extend the selectivity profile of compound 8 and 11 against a wide array of MPs. Moreover, we wanted to elucidate the key molecular interactions responsible for the enhanced selectivity profile of this series of compounds. For this purpose we generated co-crystals and solved the structures of marimastat, compound 8, and compound 11 in complex with the catalytic domain of recombinant human ADAMTS-5.