Elevated CO2 differentially alters the responses of coocurring birch and maple seedlings to a moisture gradient

Summary To determine the effects of elevated CO₂ and soil moisture status on growth and niche characteristics of birch and maple seedlings, gray birch (Betula populifolia) and red maple (Acer rubrum) were experimentally raised along a soil moisture gradient ranging from extreme drought to flooded conditions at both ambient and elevated atmospheric CO₂ levels. The magnitude of growth enhancement due to CO₂ was largely contingent on soil moisture conditions, but differently so for maple than for birch seedlings. Red maple showed greatest CO₂ enhancements under moderately moist soil conditions, whereas gray birch showed greatest enhancements under moderately dry soil conditions. Additionally, CO₂ had a relatively greater ameliorating effect in flooded conditions for red maple than for gray birch, whereas the reverse pattern was true for these species under extreme drought conditions. For both species, elevated CO₂ resulted in a reduction in niche breadths on the moisture gradient; 5% for gray birch and 23% for red maple. Species niche overlap (proportional overall) was also lower at elevated CO₂ (0.98 to: 0.88: 11%). This study highlights the utility of of experiments crossing CO₂ levels with gradients of other resources as effective tools for elucidating the potential consequences of elevated CO₂ on species distributions and potential interactions in natural communities.