Evaluation of three techniques used to determine surfactant phytotoxicity

Three techniques were used to measure and compare the phytotoxicities of Triton X-45 and Agral 90 (two organic surfactants) with two organosilicone surfactants (Silwet L-77 and L-7607), and to compare these four non-ionic compounds with a cationic tallow amine surfactant (Hyspray). Total ion efflux and ethylene response methods were used in vivo and in vitro, while a betacyanin efflux method was an in vitro system only. The first two methods, using intact leaves, were considered to be more closely related to normal spraying conditions than the betacyanin efflux test which used explant material. However, the use of intact leaves was thought to bias the results in favour of the leaf penetration properties of the surfactants rather than their phytotoxicities. The in vitro pigment efflux method provided a simple way of ranking the surfactants in order of their potential phytotoxicities, especially with regard to effects on membrane permeability. This ranking, in increasing order of toxicity, was: Silwet L-7607, Silwet L-77, Agral 90, Triton X-45 and Hyspray.