Evaluation of phosphorus in forest soils: Comparison of phosphorus uptake,extraction method and soil properties

Summary Phosphorus in soils from plantation of red pine (Pinus resinosa Ait.) was determined using six extractants: 0.002N H₂SO₄ (pH 3.0); 0.025N HCl+ +0.03N NH₄F; 0.5N NaHCO₃ (pH 8.5);N NH₄OAc (pH 4.8); anion exchange resin (Dower –2, Cl-form); H₂O. Correlations of extractable P with Al- and Al-+Fe-P indicated that these fractions are the dominant forms of inorganic P in most of the soils.Uptake of P by corn and Monterey pine seedlings grown in greenhouse culture was correlated with soil P extracted by the different methods. The most successful of the extractants for predicting P uptake was resin extractable P; the simple correlation coefficients were 0.811 and 0.609 for pine and corn respectively. P uptake by pine correlated significantly with 0.002N H₂SO₄ P (r=0.679),N NH₄OAc P (r=0.443), H₂O P (r=0.549) and Al-+Fe-P (r=0.532) while P uptake by corn correlated with 0.002N H₂SO₄ P (r=0.579), H₂O P (r=0.477) and organic P (r=0.460). Per cent P in pine seedling tops correlated significantly with 0.002N H₂SO₄, resin andN NH₄ OAc extractable P. Multiple regressions which included silt+clay and organic P improved correlations of some soil tests with P uptake in corn and pine seedlings respectively.Research supported by the School of Natural Resources, College of Agricultural and Life Sciences, Univ. of Wisconsin, Madison, the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources and FAO Fellowship to the senior author.