Reliability of the resorcinol method for identifying isomorphic phases in the Gigartinaceae (Rhodophyta)

The Gigartinaceae are economically important because the carrageenans in this family are used for a variety of purposes including food stabilizers, food substitutes, pharmaceutical applications and cosmetics. The resorcinol method takes advantage of the different carrageenans found in life history phases in this family to identify nonreproductive phases, and consequently, a better understanding of the biology of this economically important family is possible. This study investigates sources of variability that could affect the accuracy of the resorcinol method in identifying phases within the Gigartinaceae. Vegetative disks of Iridaea splendens from different areas of the blade and disks containing reproductive structures all reacted consistently to the resorcinol reagent. The minimum size and testing conditions required to reliably identify phases at the germling stage of I. splendens were determined. Phases of I. splendens cannot be identified if blades are stored in 3% formaldehyde in seawater. Phases of I. splendens, I. lineare, I. heterocarpa, Rhodoglossum californicum and R. affine can be identified reliably at different times of the year. Manipulations of the resorcinol method improved its accuracy in identifying phases of Iridaea cornucopiae and Gigartina exasperata but the high percent of G. exasperata misidentified demonstrates that it cannot be assumed that the current resorcinol method works for all taxa in the Gigartinaceae.