Plant versus prey resources: Influence on omnivore behavior and herbivore suppression

Conservation biological control tactics, such as beetle banks, that increase habitat complexity generally increase epigeal predator abundance. Habitat complexity also increases alternative food which can attract and sustain predators but may reduce predation of target pests. Our goal was to determine how alternative food from different trophic levels (fly pupae and seeds) affects behavior and biological control efficacy of omnivorous carabid beetles. Seed subsidies increased omnivorous carabid abundance more than pupae by increasing aggregation and reducing emigration. Laboratory experiment demonstrated that both omnivorous carabid species preferred seeds and pupae over cutworms. However, in field cages seeds but not pupae resulted in greater cutworm damage to corn seedlings. Our results indicate that omnivorous carabids have a stronger behavioral response to seeds than prey such that only seeds influence aggregation, emigration, and crop damage. Interestingly, whereas seeds increased omnivorous carabid abundance, pupae had no affect on carnivore abundance. Thus, carabid guild composition is skewed in favor of omnivores when seed density increases. An important finding was that the effect of seeds on behavior, predation, and crop damage was consistent among replicate carabid species suggesting our results pertain to other omnivorous species in resource diverse habitats.Our results provide insight into the mechanisms underlying the unpredictable benefit of conservation biological control tactics that alter habitat complexity.