Variation in heritability of immune function in the tree swallow

Heritability is an important component of the ability of a trait to respond to natural selection; variation in heritability can lead to differences in how a trait responds to selection pressures. Here we test whether an important physiological trait, immune function, varies by comparing heritability estimates through cross-fostering brood manipulation at three wide-spread sites in the tree swallow (Tachycineta bicolor): Alaska, New York and Tennessee. In two of three sites, there was no additive genetic component to nestling immune response to the mitogen phytohaemagglutinin, while immune response had a heritable component in Tennessee. Bootstrapping revealed significant differences in estimated heritability. This conclusion was supported by mother–offspring regressions; in Tennessee breeding females mounting strong immune responses tended to have offspring with strong immune responses, while in New York and Alaska, there was no relationship between the immune responses of mothers and offspring. These results suggest that studies investigating the roles of common origin and rearing environment should consider yearly or spatial variation within a species.