Paleopigment evidence of competition between phytoplankton and a cyanobacterial algal mat in a meromictic lake near Toronto,Ontario Canada

Crawford Lake, a meromictic lake located near Toronto, Canada, was cored to determine if algal pigments preserved in its sediments would make it possible to infer past changes in lake productivity over the last five hundred years. From 1500 to 1910 A.D. the sediments display extremely high levels of oscillaxanthin and myxoxanthophyll while chlorophyll derivatives and total carotenoids were relatively low. As the lake became increasingly more eutrophic in the latter part of the twentieth century, this relationship reversed itself. Competition for light between the deep dwelling cyanobacteria in the algal mat on the lake's bottom (8–14 m) and phytoplankton in the overlying surface layers of the water column (5–7 m) was attributed to the observed reduction in oscillaxanthin and myxoxanthophyll as Crawford Lake eutrophied. Because the major cyanobacteria in Crawford Lake are benthic mat forming Lyngbya and Oscillatoria, and not phytoplankton, competition for light with the overlying phytoplankton is critical in determining the total quantity of oscillaxanthin and myxoxanthophyll preserved in the lake's profundal sediments. These findings have major implications for the use of cyanobacterial pigments as indicators of lake trophic status in lakes where benthic algal mats are present.