A Conserved Proline between Domains II and III of Hepatitis C Virus NS5A Influences both RNA Replication and Virus Assembly

We previously demonstrated that two closely spaced polyproline motifs, with the consensus sequence Pro-X-X-Pro-X-Lys/Arg, located between residues 343 to 356 of NS5A, mediated interactions with cellular SH3 domains. The N-terminal motif (termed PP2.1) is only conserved in genotype 1 isolates, whereas the C-terminal motif (PP2.2) is conserved throughout all hepatitis C virus (HCV) isolates, although this motif was shown to be dispensable for replication of the genotype 1b subgenomic replicon. In order to investigate the potential role of these motifs in the viral life cycle, we have undertaken a detailed mutagenic analysis of these proline residues in the context of both genotype 1b (FK5.1) or 2a subgenomic replicons and the genotype 2a infectious clone, JFH-1. We show that the PP2.2 motif is dispensable for RNA replication of all subgenomic replicons and, furthermore, is not required for virus production in JFH-1. In contrast, the PP2.1 motif is only required for genotype 1b RNA replication. Mutation of proline 346 within PP2.1 to alanine dramatically attenuated genotype 1b replicon replication in three distinct genetic backgrounds, but the corresponding proline 342 was not required for replication of the JFH-1 subgenomic replicon. However, the P342A mutation resulted in both a delay to virus release and a modest (up to 10-fold) reduction in virus production. These data point to critical roles for these proline residues at multiple stages in the HCV life cycle; however, they also caution against extrapolation of data from culture-adapted replicons to infectious virus.Hepatitis C virus (HCV) is an enveloped RNA virus which is estimated to infect some 123 million individuals (24). In the majority of cases the virus establishes a chronic infection that can ultimately result in liver fibrosis, cirrhosis, or hepatocellular carcinoma. Thus, there is great interest in elucidating the mechanisms of viral replication, with a view to developing new chemotherapeutic agents. Since 1999, use of the subgenomic replicon system has led to significant progress in the understanding of the mechanism of viral RNA replication. It has been demonstrated that the five nonstructural proteins—NS3, NS4A, NS4B, NS5A, and NS5B—are necessary and sufficient to replicate an RNA molecule containing the 5′ and 3′ untranslated regions (UTRs) of the viral genome. However, apart from the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (NS5B), the precise details of the roles of each of the nonstructural proteins in the process of RNA replication remain undefined. One problem associated with the subgenomic replicon system is the observation that the replicon RNA undergoes culture adaptation in which, as a result of the error-prone nature of the polymerase, mutations that confer enhanced replicative capacity are selected for in culture. Importantly, it has been shown using the chimpanzee model that, once engineered back into an infectious clone of the virus, such mutations may be attenuating in vivo (5). Recently, the HCV field has been revolutionized by the development of a cell culture infectious system based on a genotype 2a clone derived from a patient with fulminant hepatitis: the JFH-1 clone (30). JFH-1 is also unique in that subgenomic replicons derived from this clone are able to replicate efficiently without culture adaptation. This observation, as well as the fact that full-length genomes of JFH-1 are able to coordinate the coupling of RNA replication to packaging and release of infectious virus particles in Huh7 cells, points to fundamental differences between the RNA replication machinery of JFH-1 and that of the genotype 1b culture-adapted replicons.The majority of mutations conferring culture adaptation map to the region coding for the NS5A protein. NS5A is a zinc-binding phosphoprotein that, as well as playing a critical role in RNA replication, also interacts with a plethora of cellular proteins (18). The protein has been demonstrated to consist of three domains separated by low-complexity sequences (LCS) (29). Of particular interest is the observation that within LCS2 (between domains II and III) (Fig. ​(Fig.1a),1a), NS5A contains two closely spaced polyproline motifs that are able to bind to the SH3 domains of Src-family tyrosine kinases (16), as well as other SH3 domain containing proteins (e.g., Grb2 and amphiphysin II/Bin1) (23, 25, 33). These motifs, which we have termed PP2.1 and PP2.2 (Fig. ​(Fig.1a),1a), conform to the consensus SH3 binding motif Pro-X-X-Pro-X-Arg/Lys, where X is any amino acid (21). Interestingly, although the C-terminal motif (PP2.2) is absolutely conserved in all HCV genotypes, we and others have shown that it is dispensable for HCV RNA replication because alanine substitution of three prolines in this motif (shown to abolish SH3 domain interactions 16]) within a culture-adapted subgenomic replicon had either no effect (19) or resulted in only a modest reduction in replicative capacity (23, 33). The N-terminal motif (PP2.1), however, is only conserved in genotype 1 isolates, although within this motif a proline at residue 346 in genotype 1b (342 in genotype 2a) is absolutely conserved throughout all genotypes, which suggests it has an important role in virus replication.Open in a separate windowFIG. 1.Polyproline motifs in NS5A. (a) Schematic of the structure of NS5A showing the endoplasmic reticulum-membrane associating amphipathic helix (gray box) (4), the position of the coordinated zinc ion, and the three domains with interlinking LCS (black boxes) (29). The lower part of this figure shows the amino acid sequence of the region from residues 343 to 356. These correspond to polyprotein residues 2315 to 2328 in the genotype 1b infectious clone J4 (31). Note that in JFH-1 the corresponding residues in the polyprotein are 2311 to 2325 (residues 339 to 352 within the NS5A sequence). The prolines and basic residues of the SH3 binding motifs (Pro-X-X-Pro-X-Arg/Lys) are in boldface. The accession numbers for the six sequences are as follows: 1a infectious clone H77 (AF009606), 1b infectious clone J4 (AF054247), FK5.1 culture-adapted subgenomic replicon (AJ242654) (13), Con1 isolate (AJ238799), 2a infectious clone JFH-1 (AB047639), and 3a isolate (D17763). (b) Schematic of mutants constructed in the present study. The wild-type FK5.1 sequence is on the top line, residues mutated to alanine indicated by A in the subsequent lines, hyphens indicate unchanged residues.To shed more light on the role of these proline residues in the viral life cycle we have undertaken a mutagenic analysis both in the context of genotype 1b or 2a subgenomic replicons and the cell culture infectious JFH-1 clone. Our results point to key roles of these prolines in multiple stages of virus replication but highlight a surprising discrepancy between the requirements in the two systems.