| Abstract: | Abstract Mathematical models of interacting populations have a prominent position in population and community ecology, but are often criticized for not being testable. The authors reviewed tests of a particular model, the exploitation ecosystem hypothesis as it was formulated in Oksanen et al. (1981), in order to study problems that may be encountered when testing models. A general problem is how to determine if an experimental system should be regarded as within the model's theoretical domain or not. The theoretical domain defines the type of system the model is meant to apply to. It is noted that both liberal and strict domain definitions can be problematic. Most important is that a too liberal domain definition can result in false understanding (i.e. that it is falsely concluded that the processes included in the model are controlling the study system). Other problems encountered were more system‐specific. Equilibrium predictions were tested in experiments that were too short to reach steady state and in several studies ambiguous definitions and measurements of model variables were found such as productivity, biomass and the number trophic levels. It is concluded that a major obstacle when performing tests is the conceptual and methodological problems encountered when translating model abstractions into an empirical reality. |
