Rearranged JC Virus Noncoding Control Regions Found in Progressive Multifocal Leukoencephalopathy Patient Samples Increase Virus Early Gene Expression and Replication Rate

Polyomavirus JC (JCV) infects ∼60% of the general population, followed by asymptomatic urinary shedding in ∼20%. In patients with pronounced immunodeficiency, including HIV/AIDS, JCV can cause progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML), a devastating brain disease of high mortality. While JCV in the urine of healthy people has a linear noncoding control region called the archetype NCCR (at-NCCR), JCV in brain and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of PML patients bear rearranged NCCRs (rr-NCCRs). Although JCV NCCR rearrangements are deemed pathognomonic for PML, their role as a viral determinant is unclear. We sequenced JCV NCCRs found in CSF of eight HIV/AIDS patients newly diagnosed with PML and analyzed their effect on early and late gene expression using a bidirectional reporter vector recapitulating the circular polyomavirus early and late gene organization. The rr-NCCR sequences were highly diverse, but all increased viral early reporter gene expression in progenitor-derived astrocytes, glia-derived cells, and human kidney compared to the expression levels with the at-NCCR. The expression of simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen or HIV Tat expression in trans was associated with a strong increase of at-NCCR-controlled early gene expression, while rr-NCCRs were less responsive. The insertion of rr-NCCRs into the JCV genome backbone revealed higher viral replication rates for rr-NCCR compared to those of the at-NCCR JCV in human progenitor-derived astrocytes or glia cells, which was abrogated in SV40 large T-expressing COS-7 cells. We conclude that naturally occurring JCV rr-NCCR variants from PML patients confer increased early gene expression and higher replication rates compared to those of at-NCCR JCV and thereby increase cytopathology.Polyomavirus JC (JCV) infects approximately 60% of the general population, followed by asymptomatic urinary shedding in 20% of healthy individuals (20). Although JCV-associated nephropathy may occur in kidney transplant (14, 33) and HIV/AIDS patients (6, 27), the most prominent JCV disease is progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML) (44, 60). The pathology of PML was first described in 1958 as a rare complication of patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia or Hodgkin''s lymphoma (3). Today, PML is recognized as a rare, virus-mediated demyelinating disease of the white brain matter in highly immunocompromised patients, including HIV/AIDS, transplantation, and chemotherapy patients and those exposed to immunomodulatory or depleting biologicals for the treatment of autoimmune diseases (29, 40). During the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) pandemic, the incidence of PML rose significantly to rates of 1 to 8% prior to the use of highly active antiretroviral therapy (2, 5, 34). The definitive diagnosis requires brain tissue, but the detection of JCV by PCR in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) is generally accepted for a laboratory-confirmed diagnosis in immunocompromised patients with (multi-)focal neurological deficits and corresponding radiological findings (8, 26). Due to the lack of effective antiviral therapy (13), the treatment of PML is based on improving overall immune functions. While this is difficult to achieve in cancer, chemotherapy, and transplantation, prompt antiretroviral therapy in HIV/AIDS patients has significantly improved PML survival, with increasing JCV-specific immune responses and declining intracerebral JCV replication (7, 15, 23, 35, 37). In patients diagnosed with PML after treatment with natalizumab for multiple sclerosis or inflammatory bowel disease, the removal of the monoclonal antibody by plasmapheresis has been tried to restore lymphocyte homing to, and the immune surveillance of, JCV replication sites in the central nervous system (38, 40, 52). However, the success of immune reconstitution in HIV/AIDS- and natalizumab-associated PML cases is limited by the fact that PML is typically diagnosed clinically by neurological deficits resulting from significant brain damage, where mounting antiviral immunity often may be too slow to modify the outcome. On the other hand, rapid recovery may cause immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome with paradoxical clinical worsening and fatal outcomes (9, 16, 25, 38, 46). Although the etiologic role of JCV in PML is well documented, the pathogenesis and, in particular, the role of viral determinants is less clear. Virtually all JCV strains isolated from the brain or CSF of PML patients are characterized by highly variable genomic rearrangements of the noncoding control region (NCCR), which governs viral early and late genes in opposite directions of the circular polyomavirus DNA genome (1, 4, 31, 39, 41, 43, 49, 54, 59). In contrast, JCV detected in the urine of immunocompetent individuals show a consistent linear architecture called the archetype NCCR (at-NCCR). Thus, detecting rearranged NCCRs (rr-NCCRs) JCV in the central nervous system has been viewed as being derived from the archetype and closely linked to PML (4), but the functional consequences of rearrangements are unclear. To address the consequences of the rr-NCCR for JCV gene expression and replication, we characterized the sequences of JCV rr-NCCR from patients with PML and analyzed their effect on viral gene expression and replication with JCV at-NCCR in a bidirectional reporter assay and in recombinant JCV.