Deciphering the oxygen isotope composition of nitrous oxide produced by nitrification

The ability to use δ¹⁸O values of nitrous oxide (N₂O) to apportion environmental emissions is currently hindered by a poor understanding of the controls on δ¹⁸O–N₂O from nitrification (hydroxylamine oxidation to N₂O and nitrite reduction to N₂O). In this study fertilized agricultural soils and unfertilized temperate forest soils were aerobically incubated with different ¹⁸O/¹⁶O waters, and conceptual and mathematical models were developed to systematically explain the δ¹⁸O–N₂O formed by nitrification. Modeling exercises used a set of defined input parameters to emulate the measured soil δ¹⁸O–N₂O data (Monte Carlo approach). The Monte Carlo simulations implied that abiotic oxygen (O) exchange between nitrite (NO₂^?) and H₂O is important in all soils, but that biological, enzyme‐controlled O‐exchange does not occur during the reduction of NO₂^? to N₂O (nitrifier‐denitrification). Similarly, the results of the model simulations indicated that N₂O consumption is not characteristic of aerobic N₂O formation. The results of this study and a synthesis of the published literature data indicate that δ¹⁸O–N₂O formed in aerobic environments is constrained between +13‰ and +35‰ relative to Vienna Standard Mean Ocean Water (VSMOW). N₂O formed via hydroxylamine oxidation and nitrifier‐denitrification cannot be separated using δ¹⁸O unless ¹⁸O tracers are employed. The natural range of nitrifier δ¹⁸O–N₂O is discussed and explained in terms of our conceptual model, and the major and minor controls that define aerobically produced δ¹⁸O–N₂O are identified. Despite the highly complex nature of δ¹⁸O–N₂O produced by nitrification this δ¹⁸O range is narrow. As a result, in many situations δ¹⁸O values may be used in conjunction with δ¹⁵N–N₂O data to apportion nitrifier‐ and denitrifier‐derived N₂O. However, when biological O‐exchange during denitrification is high and N₂O consumption is low, there may be too much overlap in δ¹⁸O values to distinguish N₂O formed by these pathways.