Determinants of growth rate on chemically heterogeneous host plants by specialist insects

Nine Passiflora species growing sympatrically in a Costa Rican rain forest were screened for the presence of alkaloids, tannins, cyanogenic compounds, saponins and cardenolides. The first three chemical classes were found to be present and the Passiflora species could be classified into five groups according to the presence/absence of each chemical class. In order to assess the effects of this chemical variability on specialist herbivores, larvae of Heliconius ismenius and H. melpomane were experimentally introduced to seven species of Passiflora host plants growing naturally in the rain forest. Survival and growth rates were subsequently monitored at 2 day intervals and were found to be independent of each other. Larval growth rate and larval survivorship were not significantly affected by cyanogenesis in the host plants, nor by the presence of alkaloids, tannins and non-tanning phenolic compounds. Larval growth rate was found to be correlated to percentage nitrogen in the host plants, but was independent of host water content and non-structural carbohydrate content. Although these insects would be classified as host-specific by most authors, the results indicate the presence of a sufficiently general detoxication apparatus to consume many different classes of potential toxins with no apparent ill effects. We conclude that Passiflora natural product diversity does not cause major deleterious effects in Heliconius growth characteristics and that these effects are not the major component maintaining the current pattern of larval feeding specialization in this plant-herbivore system.