Comparative study of RT23 and IC-65 tuberculins tested on children with tuberculosis

This study, conducted in 2009, proposed to evaluate and compare the biological potency of two different tuberculins, RT23 (Statens Serum Institute, Copenhagen) and IC-65 (Cantacuzino Institute, Bucharest) when administered to 89 children with confirmed tuberculosis, admitted to Paediatric Department of Pneumophtysiology Institute, Bucharest. Mean age of subjects was 10.4 years SD (standard deviation) = 5.2 years; variance = 27.2], and sex distribution in the group was: 55.1% girls and 44.9% boys. Tuberculin skin tests were performed using Mantoux method simultaneously with the two tuberculins in the same concentration, 2TU (tuberculin units)/0.1 ml. RT23 skin test reactions ranged from 8 mm to 18 mm (mean = 12.8 mm, SD = 2.1 mm, variance = 4.4; median = 12.0), and IC-65 reactions ranged from 8 mm to 18 mm (mean = 13.1 mm; SD = 2.1 mm; variance = 4.3; median = 13.0). The mean difference in paired reaction sizes for the two reagents was 0.04 mm and was not statistically different from zero (P value = 0.3). The difference in reaction sizes was = 2 mm in 70.8% and = 5 mm in 7.9% patients. With a cutoff of 10 mm to define a positive reaction, the results were highly correlated with a sensitivity of 98.9% for RT23 and 97.8% for IC-65. No statistically significant difference was established for the efficacy of the two commercially available PPD TST reagents, both tuberculins appearing to have equivalent potency.