| Abstract: | Soil nutrient availability may affect both the amount of damage that plants receive from herbivores and the ability of plants to recover from herbivory, but these two factors are rarely considered together. In the experiment reported here, I examined how soil fertility influenced both the degree of defoliation and compensation for herbivory for Brassica nigra plants damaged by Pieris rapae caterpillars. Realistic levels of defoliation were obtained by placing caterpillars on potted host plants early in the life cycle and allowing them to feed until just before pupation on the designated plant. Percent defoliation was more than twice as great at low soil fertility compared to high (48.2% and 21.0%, respectively), even though plants grown at high soil fertility lost a greater absolute amount of leaf area (38.2 cm2 and 22.1 cm2, respectively). At both low and high soil fertility, total seed number and mean mass per seed of damaged plants were equivalent to those of undamaged plants. Thus soil fertility did not influence plant compensation in terms of maternal fitness. However, the pathways used to achieve compensation in seed production were different at low and high soil fertility. At low soil fertility, relative leaf growth rates (area added per inital area per day) of damaged plants were drastically reduced over the second week of caterpillar feeding. Damaged plants recovered the leaf area lost to herbivory in the two weeks following insect removal by increasing leaf relative growth rates above the levels seen for undamaged plants, but the replacement of leaf tissue lost to herbivory came at the expense of stem biomass. At high soil fertility, relative leaf growth rates of damaged plants were similar to those of undamaged plants both over the second week of caterpillar feeding and following caterpillar removal, and stem biomass was not affected by herbivory. These results suggest that higher levels of soil nutrients increased the ability of plants to stay ahead of their herbivores as they were being eaten. Because damaged plants at high soil fertility were able to maintain leaf growth rates to a greater extent than damaged plants at low soil fertility, they did not fall as far behind undamaged plants over the period of insect feeding and did not have as much catching up to do after feeding ended to compensate for herbivory. |
