Effects of cell concentration and growth period on articular and ear chondrocyte transplants for tissue engineering

This study determined the effects of chondrocyte source, cell concentration, and growth period on cartilage production when isolated porcine cells are injected subcutaneously in a nude mouse model. Chondrocytes were isolated from both ear and articular cartilage and were suspended in Ham's F-12 medium at concentrations of 10, 20, 40, and 80 million cells per cubic centimeter. Using the nude mouse model, each concentration group was injected subcutaneously in 100-microl aliquots and was allowed to incubate for 6 weeks in vivo. In addition, cells suspended at a fixed concentration of 40 million cells per cubic centimeter were injected in 100-microl aliquots and were incubated for 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 9, and 12 weeks. Each concentration or time period studied contained a total of eight mice, with four samples harvested per mouse for a final sample size of 32 constructs. All neocartilage samples were analyzed by histologic characteristics, mass, glycosaminoglycan level, and DNA content. Control groups consisted of native porcine ear and articular cartilage.Specimen mass increased with increasing concentration and incubation time. Ear neocartilage was larger than articular neocartilage at each concentration and time period. At 40 million cells per cubic centimeter, both ear and articular chondrocytes produced optimal neocartilage, without limitations in growth. Specimen mass increased with incubation time up to 6 weeks in both ear and articular samples. No significant variations in glycosaminoglycan content were found in either articular or ear neocartilage, with respect to variable chondrocyte concentration or growth period. Although articular samples demonstrated no significant trends in DNA content over time, ear specimens showed decreasing values through 6 weeks, inversely proportional to increase in specimen mass. Although both articular and ear sources of chondrocytes have been used in past tissue-engineering studies with success, this study indicates that a suspension of ear chondrocytes injected into a subcutaneous location will produce biochemical and histologic data with greater similarity to those of native cartilage. The authors believe that this phenomenon is attributable to the local environment in which isolated chondrocytes from different sources are introduced. The subcutaneous environment of native ear cartilage accommodates subcutaneously injected ear chondrocyte transplants better than articular transplants. Native structural and biochemical cues within the local environment are believed to guide the proliferation of the differentiated chondrocytes.