Scramble competition polygyny in the milkweed leaf beetle: combat, mobility, and the importance of being there

I examined the scramble competition mating system of the milkweedleaf beetle, Labidomera clivicollis(Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae),using data on lifetime mating success of two breeding cohortsin Austin, Texas, USA (30° N, 97° W) and one in Bridgeport,New York, USA (43° N, 76° W). Data from six daily censuseswere combined with focal animal samples to examine the importanceof combat between males and to evaluate the extent to whichthe characters elytron length, vagility, and emergence datewere correlated with male mating success. In both populations,emergence date was the only consistent determinant of the numberof mates a male obtained during his lifetime. Males emergingearlier in the season had higher mating success because theywere active for more of the breeding season. Male body size(elytron length) was not correlated with mating efficiency orlifetime mating success in either population. Males formed prolongedmating associations with females that lasted for up to 2.5 daysand paired males in the New York population had a strong advantageover interlopers attempting to mate with the female. Only 10%of takeover attempts were successful. Selection favored vagilemales in New York, where the sex ratio was male biased, butnot in Texas, where it was female biased. Males that were morevagile had higher mating efficiencies in New York but did nothave higher lifetime mating success because of a trade-off betweenmating efficiency and survival. Behavioral data demonstratedthat lone males spent more time walking and less time feedingthan lone females; mating males were unable to feed at all.The survival disadvantage that comes with increased vagilitymay be due to loss of time spent feeding. The characters examinedsuggest that the most important thing a male L. clivicolliscan do to increase his lifetime mating success is to be presentfor as much of the breeding season as possible.