A Comparison of Methods for Plasmid Delivery into Plant Protoplasts

Three methods of plasmid delivery to mesophyll protoplasts ofNicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi have been evaluated. Specifically;a) chemically stimulated uptake of isolated plasmid, b) deliveryof plasmid encapsulated in liposomes, and c) fusion of plasmid-containingspheroplasts, were combined with divalent cation (Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺)or polyalcohol polyethylene glycol (PEG) and polyvinyl alcohol(PVA)] treatments. The quantity and quality of plasmid associatedwith intact protoplasts, was assessed by DNA-DNA blot hybridisationanalysis, following stringent washing to separate intact protoplastsfrom non-viable protoplasts and debris. Treatments which increasedassociation of plasmid with protoplasts decreased protoplastviability. Optimum association of plasmid with protoplasts,in the context of acceptable loss of viability, was achievedwhen protoplasts were interacted with either naked plasmid orliposomeencapsulated DNA in the presence of 15% w/v PEG 6000,or with Escherichia coli spheroplasts containing chloramphenicol-amplifiedplasmid in the presence of 25% w/v PEG 6000. Divalent cationsdid not stimulate significant plasmid delivery without unacceptableloss of protoplast viability. Strategies to further increasethe efficiency of plasmid delivery are discussed. (Received June 21, 1984; Accepted August 20, 1984)