Intensive sampling and transplantation experiments reveal continued effects of episodic acidification on sensitive stream invertebrates

1. Although mean pH is increasing in acidified streams throughout Europe, benthic invertebrates are recovering only slowly. One developing hypothesis is that acid episodes continue to restrict recolonisation and recovery. Here, we used intra‐annual sampling in replicate circumneutral, acid and episodic streams at the Llyn Brianne experimental catchments to assess possible mayfly exposure to episodic effects quantified from a risk index based on long‐term discharge. Episodic effects were then tested using short‐term transplantations of animals in enclosures. 2. No mayflies occurred in acid streams while Baetis rhodani occurred in episodic streams but declined to zero density following low pH in autumn. Ephemerella ignita, Baetis vernus, B. muticus, Rhithrogena semicolorata, Ecdyonurus spp. and Heptagenia lateralis occurred only in the circumneutral streams. The first two species were present as nymphs only during July and August so that episodic exposure risk was minimal, but the remaining species occurred as nymphs in all months. 3. Baetis rhodani transplanted during base‐flow (September 2003) and high‐flow (April 2004) were exposed to either; (i) continual (chronic) exposure in the acid streams over 16 days or (ii) repeated short‐term (episodic) exposure to acid conditions for 2 × 4 day periods interspersed with 4‐day recovery periods in the circumneutral streams. Baetis survival in the circumneutral streams (always pH > 5.7) remained high during both low‐ and high‐flow. By comparison, mortality increased (P < 0.01) during chronic and episodic exposure, but only during high‐flow (mean pH 3.8–3.9, cf. 5.5–5.8 at low flow) when mortality varied significantly in the order chronic (>80%) > episodic (>40%) >circumneutral (<10%). 4. We conclude that, despite Europe‐wide trends towards chemical recovery from acidification, even short exposures to high‐flow events at Llyn Brianne are still sufficiently acid to reduce the survival of B. rhodani. Most mayfly species absent from acid and episodic streams have life cycles that would increase acid exposure risks during autumn and winter, and this may be sufficient to explain their current distribution.