Development in Berthella californica (Gastropoda: Opisthobranchia) with comparative observations on phylogenetically relevant larval characters among nudipleuran opisthobranchs

Abstract. Morphological criteria defining the Nudipleura and sister group relationships among the three nudipleuran subgroups (pleurobranchoideans, anthobranch nudibranchs, and cladobranch nudibranchs) have been controversial. Analysis of larval stages may help resolve these uncertainties by identifying additional phylogenetically informative characters, but existing information on pleurobranchoidean larvae is meager. We studied larval development and metamorphosis of the pleurobranchoidean Berthella californica using histological sections, scanning and transmission electron microscopy, and immunolabeling of neurons within the larval apical ganglion. We also provide comparative data on other nudipleuran larvae that may be useful for phylogenetic reconstruction. Berthella californica fills a previously unoccupied place within an evolutionary scenario that derives nudibranchs from pleurobranchoideans, two groups in which the larval mantle fold forms the post‐metamorphic notum (dorsal epidermis). In B. californica, reflection of the mantle fold epithelium to form the notum begins at metamorphosis, as also occurs in nudibranchs, whereas mantle reflection in other pleurobranchoideans begins well before metamorphosis. Dissolution of overgrown shell walls inside the protoconch and formation of the post‐metamorphic notum from the inner epithelium of the larval mantle fold may be synapomorphies of the Nudipleura. The larval shell in B. californica is additionally noteworthy because it acquires bilateral symmetry later in development, which is very unusual among larval opisthobranchs. We demonstrate an osphradium in the larvae of two pleurobranchoideans and one anthobranch nudibranch, although adults lack this trait. We also identified an autapomorphy of cladobranch nudibranchs in the form of five ampullary neurons within the larval apical ganglion, whereas other planktotrophic opisthobranch larvae have only four of these neurons. Although our data provide morphological criteria defining both the Nudipleura and the cladobranch nudibranchs, they are insufficient to resolve sister group relationships within the Nudipleura.