Functional Switching and Stability of Regulatory T Cells

It is widely accepted that the primary immune system contains a subpopulation of cells, known as regulatory T cells whose function is to regulate the immune response. There is conflicting biological evidence regarding the ability of regulatory cells to lose their regulatory capabilities and turn into immune promoting cells. In this paper, we develop mathematical models to investigate the effects of regulatory T cell switching on the immune response. Depending on environmental conditions, regulatory T cells may transition, becoming effector T cells that are immunostimulatory rather than immunoregulatory. We consider this mechanism both in the context of a simple, ordinary differential equation (ODE) model and in the context of a more biologically detailed, delay differential equation (DDE) model of the primary immune response. It is shown that models that incorporate such a mechanism express the usual characteristics of an immune response (expansion, contraction, and memory phases), while being more robust with respect to T cell precursor frequencies. We characterize the affects of regulatory T cell switching on the peak magnitude of the immune response and identify a biologically testable range for the switching parameter. We conclude that regulatory T cell switching may play a key role in controlling immune contraction.