| Abstract: | A recent clinical trial of a T-cell-based AIDS vaccine delivered with recombinant adenovirus type 5 (rAd5) vectors showed no efficacy in lowering viral load and was associated with increased risk of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) infection. Preexisting immunity to Ad5 in humans could therefore affect both immunogenicity and vaccine efficacy. We hypothesized that vaccine-induced immunity is differentially affected, depending on whether subjects were exposed to Ad5 by natural infection or by vaccination. Serum samples from vaccine trial subjects receiving a DNA/rAd5 AIDS vaccine with or without prior immunity to Ad5 were examined for the specificity of their Ad5 neutralizing antibodies and their effect on HIV-1 immune responses. Here, we report that rAd5 neutralizing antibodies were directed to different components of the virion, depending on whether they were elicited by natural infection or vaccination in HIV vaccine trial subjects. Neutralizing antibodies elicited by natural infection were directed largely to the Ad5 fiber, while exposure to rAd5 through vaccination elicited antibodies primarily to capsid proteins other than fiber. Notably, preexisting immunity to Ad5 fiber from natural infection significantly reduced the CD4 and CD8 cell responses to HIV Gag after DNA/rAd5 vaccination. The specificity of Ad5 neutralizing antibodies therefore differs depending on the route of exposure, and natural Ad5 infection compromises Ad5 vaccine-induced immunity to weak immunogens, such as HIV-1 Gag. These results have implications for future AIDS vaccine trials and the design of next-generation gene-based vaccine vectors.Recombinant adenovirus (rAd)-based vectors are currently under investigation in a variety of gene therapy and T-cell-based vaccine clinical trials. There are more than 370 such ongoing clinical trials for broad applications, including infectious diseases and cancer therapy (http://www.wiley.co.uk/genetherapy/clinical/). Based on supportive data from nonhuman primate studies, rAd-based vectors have been developed and tested in human clinical trials to deliver human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) gene products that stimulate HIV-specific immune responses. Preexisting immunity to Ad serotype 5 (Ad5), from which most vectors are derived, is common in humans. Though neutralizing antibodies to Ad5 may reduce the immunogenicity of Ad5-based vectors in animal models (16), their effect on immunity in subjects with previous Ad5 infection is poorly understood. In the STEP trial, which tested a Merck rAd5 vaccine encoding HIV-1 Gag, Pol, and Nef, vaccination failed to show protection, either by lowering viral load or by decreasing acquisition of infection (3, 9, 12, 21). Furthermore, the possibility was raised that subjects with preexisting neutralizing antibodies from natural Ad5 infection may have carried an increased risk of HIV infection after vaccination. Thus, understanding the nature and immune effects of Ad5 seropositivity in humans is important to the development of vaccines against AIDS and other diseases.Ad5 is a common cause of respiratory disease and an occasional cause of gastroenteritis in humans, and exposure before adolescence is common in human populations (19). Such exposure stimulates both innate and adaptive immune responses that generate neutralizing antibodies and virus-specific T-cell responses (6). These antibodies can also synergize with each other to achieve maximum viral neutralization (7, 22). The capsid protein specificity of Ad5 neutralizing antibodies has been reported for humans following administration of rAd5 gene therapy vectors for advanced liver or lung cancer (7, 10). However, results were presented solely for antibodies induced by administration of rAd5. One report has assessed Ad5 neutralizing antibodies with a healthy human population that was Ad5 seropositive from natural exposure to the virus (18). The median titer of the population was presented, but the frequency of protein-specific neutralizing antibody has not been defined for humans.Here we describe the first report of the natural frequency and effect on immunization of neutralizing antibodies specific for different Ad capsid proteins in human subjects. We address the fundamental mechanisms of how humans generate neutralizing antibodies to a common cold virus that is in widespread use as a vector for gene therapy and vaccines. Such mechanisms may also be applicable to other nonenveloped viruses, including adeno-associated viruses and other viruses containing multiple envelope surface proteins, like influenza. To analyze the contribution of anti-capsid antibodies to neutralization by different human serum samples, wild-type and chimeric vectors were utilized. For example, a rAd type 5 (rAd5) vector with a fiber derived from Ad35 fiber (rAd5 F35) can be used to analyze the anti-Ad5 capsid response independent of fiber. Conversely, a rAd35 vector with a fiber transposed from Ad5 can determine the specificity of neutralization mediated by the Ad5 fiber. Using these vectors, we have analyzed human serum samples from two HIV vaccine clinical trials, VRC 006 and HVTN 204, in which a single-dose rAd5 vaccine alone and a three-dose DNA prime/single dose rAd5 boost vaccine encoding HIV-1 Env A,B, and C; Gag; and Pol, respectively, were administered. Thus, we sought to characterize the specificity of rAd5 neutralizing antibodies in Ad5-immune subjects and to determine their effect on immune responses elicited by vaccination. |
