Comparison of heterospermic and homospermic inseminations as measures of male fertility

This study attempted to determine a basis for the previously observed greater sensitivity of heterospermic tests when compared to homospermic tests for detecting differences in fertility between males. In theory, the results of heterospermic tests are an indication of the proportion of eggs fertilized per unit time whereas results of homospermic inseminations measure only the cumulative or final proportion of eggs fertilized. The fertilizing ability of sperm from males of CF1 and C57BL/6N strains of mice was compared homospermically using both relatively high and low concentrations of sperm and by measuring the proportion of eggs penetrated per unit of time. The fertilizing ability of sperm from these strains was also compared using heterospermic inseminations. When females were inseminated with a high concentration of sperm, males of both strains fertilized a high and indistinguishable percentage of eggs when examined after 30 hr. When females were inseminated with either a low concentration of sperm or when the proportion of eggs penetrated was measured at 5 hr, differences between strains of mice were distinguishable. Heterospermic insemination further magnified the observed difference between strains. The results of this study confirm that measuring the percentage of eggs fertilized per unit of time can enhance the magnitude of differences between males in fertility as compared to measuring only the final percentage of eggs fertilized. Measuring the percentage of eggs fertilized per unit of time does not, however, entirely account for the large differences observed between fertility of males when they are compared using heterospermic inseminations.