Tree Mortality Following Boreal Forest Fires Reveals Scale-Dependant Interactions Between Community Structure and Fire Intensity

Fire disturbance patterns influence forest communities at a range of spatial scales. Forest community structure may also influence fire disturbance patterns, because tree species vary in their fuel value and in their tolerance to fire damage. However, the influence of community structure on fire disturbance likely depends on latent ecological differences between fires and on the spatial scale at which patterns are observed. Using data on fire intensity, community structure, and post-fire tree survival in four systematically sampled boreal forest fires, we tested the hypotheses that: (1) patterns in post-fire tree survival reflect interactions between fire intensity and community structure; (2) these relationships change with the spatial scale of observation. To test the first hypothesis, we used information theoretic methods to compare eight generalized linear mixed effects models describing the influence of community structure and fire intensity on tree survival in a 500 m² sample plot, accounting for latent fire-to-fire differences in response. To test the scaling hypothesis, we reaveraged the data at nine successively larger spatial resolutions up to approximately 2 km², at each resolution tracking the parameter values of the best model. When fit to the plot-level data, the dominant feature of the best model was a strong intensity–survival correlation which varied from fire to fire, and depended on plot-level community structure. In some fires, community structure and survival became more tightly coupled at larger scales, whereas fire intensity became less important. These results support the view that fire disturbance patterns are influenced by cross-scale interactions between community structure and fire intensity.