Tradeoffs Between Irradiance Capture and Avoidance in Semi-arid Environments Assessed with a Crown Architecture Model

Plants in arid environments cope with stress from excessiveirradiance by physiological photoprotection of the photosyntheticapparatus and by structurally reducing the leaf area exposedto the sun (structural photoprotection). We assessed the ecologicalrelevance of structural photoprotection in two plants of contrastingarchitecture co-occurring in a semi-arid environment, usingthe three-dimensional canopy model YPLANT. We compared the roleof crown geometry in avoiding excessive radiation, analysedthe costs of structural photoprotection in terms of reductionof potential carbon gain, and compared these costs with thosedue to seasonal constraints of photosynthesis and tissue ageing.The results of the model simulations indicated that canopy architectureofStipa tenacissima(a tussock grass) andRetama sphaerocarpa(aleafless leguminous shrub) minimized the risk of overheatingand photo-oxidative destruction of the photosynthetic apparatuswith steeply oriented foliage and moderate self-shading. Butthis structural photoprotection imposed an increased cost interms of potential carbon gain. Diurnal and seasonal patternsof light interception by the crown of these plants translatedinto a simulated potential carbon gain only half that of anequivalent, horizontal photosynthetic surface. This reductionin potential carbon gain, due to irradiance avoidance, was similarto that imposed by water shortage.S. tenacissima,which ceasesphotosynthetic activity during periods of drought, exhibitedmore structural avoidance of irradiance thanR. sphaerocarpa,whichremains active throughout the year. This illustrates the influenceof the capacity of plants to utilize light for carbon fixationon the trade-offs between irradiance capture and avoidance.Structural avoidance of excessive radiation efficiently preventsthe risk of damage by intense irradiance, has no special maintenancecosts, and is biomechanically cheaper than enhanced light harvestingby a horizontal canopy, which points to structural photoprotectionas a very effective strategy to cope with high irradiance stressin poor and adverse habitats.Copyright 1999 Annals of BotanyCompany Canopy model, functional architecture, irradiance avoidance, light harvesting, photoinhibition, photoprotection, photosynthesis model, plant architecture,Retama sphaerocarpa,semi-arid environment,Stipa tenacissima,structural photoprotection.