Searching for the bull's eye: agents and targets of selection vary among geographically disparate cyanogenesis clines in white clover (Trifolium repens L.)

The recurrent evolution of adaptive clines within a species can be used to elucidate theselective factors and genetic responses that underlie adaptation. White clover ispolymorphic for cyanogenesis (HCN release with tissue damage), and climate-associatedcyanogenesis clines have evolved throughout the native and introduced species range. Thispolymorphism arises through two independently segregating Mendelian polymorphisms for thepresence/absence of two required components: cyanogenic glucosides and theirhydrolyzing enzyme linamarase. Cyanogenesis is commonly thought to function in herbivoredefense; however, the individual cyanogenic components may also serve other physiologicalfunctions. To test whether cyanogenesis clines have evolved in response to the sameselective pressures acting on the same genetic targets, we examined cyanogenesis clineshape and its environmental correlates in three world regions: southern New Zealand, thecentral United States and the US Pacific Northwest. For some regional comparisons, clineshapes are remarkably similar despite large differences in the spatial scales over whichclines occur (40–1600 km). However, we also find evidence for majordifferences in both the agents and targets of selection among the sampled clines.Variation in cyanogenesis frequency is best predicted using a combination of minimumwinter temperature and aridity variables. Together, our results provide evidence thatrecurrent adaptive clines do not necessarily reflect shared adaptive processes.