The mutagenic activity of selected compounds at the TK locus: rodent vs. human cells |
| |
Authors: | W J Caspary R Langenbach B W Penman C Crespi B C Myhr A D Mitchell |
| |
Affiliation: | Cellular and Genetic Toxicology Branch, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709. |
| |
Abstract: | The mutagenic (TFT resistance) and toxic responses of mouse lymphoma (MOLY) L5178Y cells and human lymphoblast (HULY) TK6 cells were compared for 13 chemicals. The mutagenic activities of 8 of the 13 chemicals (62%) examined in the HULY and MOLY assays are in agreement - the results being judged positive in both assays. However, a dramatic difference is observed when the two conditions of metabolic activation are considered separately; the overall concordance of 8/13 has been achieved by combining a 13/13 (100%) agreement in the absence of S9 with a 1/6 (17%) agreement in the presence of S9. In the absence of S9, the concentration ranges, lowest significant doses, and shapes of the concentration-response curves for both toxicity and mutagenicity were similar in spite of the differences in exposure times (4 h for MOLY, 20 for HULY) and expression times (2 days for MOLY, 3 days for HULY). The general agreement observed in the absence of S9 contrasted with the differences manifested in its presence. 6 compounds which were negative in the absence of S9 were tested in both the MOLY and HULY assays in the presence of S9. Of the 6 chemicals, only 1 was positive in both MOLY and HULY under the latter condition; 4 others were positive in MOLY and negative in HULY whereas 1 was positive in HULY and negative in MOLY. |
| |
Keywords: | |
|
|