Fish predation,lake acidity and the composition of aquatic insect assemblages

Aquatic insect assemblages were sampled in 2 sets of 18 small lakes in 2 regions of northeastern Ontario. Both sets included lakes with and without fish. In the set near Sudbury, fishless lakes were acidic. Using a standardized sweep net procedure, fishless lakes in both areas were found to have a greater abundance and richness of insects than lakes with fish. Irrespective of pH, fishless lakes supported a similar aquatic insect assemblage which was characterized by an abundance of nekton, especially Notonectidae, Corixidae, Graphoderus liberus (Dytiscidae) and Chaoborus americanus (Chaoboridae). Those taxa were typically absent from lakes with fish, which often had a marked abundance of Gerridae. It is concluded that fish predation is the most immediate factor structuring such aquatic insect assemblages, and is responsible for their change coincident with lake acidification.