Contribution of methanol to the production of methane and its 13C-isotopic signature in anoxic rice field soil

Conversion of methanol to CH₄ has a large isotope effect so that a small contribution of methanol-dependent CH₄ production may decrease the ¹³CH₄ of total CH₄ production. Therefore, we investigated the role of methanol for CH₄ production. Methanol was not detectable above 10 M in anoxic methanogenic rice field soil. Nevertheless, addition of ¹³C-labeled methanol (99% enriched) resulted in immediate accumulation of ¹³CH₄. Addition of 0.1 M ¹³C-methanol resulted in increase of the ¹³CH₄ from –47 to –6 within 2 h, followed by a slow decrease. Addition of 1 M ¹³C-methanol increased ¹³CH₄ to +500 within 4 h, whereas 10 M increased ¹³CH₄ to +2500 and continued to increase. These results indicate that the methanol concentrations in situ, which diluted the ¹³C-methanol added, were 0.1 M and that the turnover of methanol contributed only about 2% to total CH₄ production at 0.1 M. However, contribution increased up to 5 and 17% when 1 and 10 M methanol were added, respectively. Anoxic rice soil that was incubated at different temperatures between 10 and 37 °C exhibited maximally 2–6% methanol-dependent methanogenesis about 1–2 h after addition of 1 M ¹³C-methanol. Only at 50 °C, contribution of methanol to CH₄ production reached a maximum of 10%. After longer (7–10 h) incubation, however, contribution generally was only 2–4%. Methanol accumulated in the soil when CH₄ production was inhibited by chloroform. However, the accumulated methanol accounted for only up to 0.7 and 1.2% of total CH₄ production at 37 and 50 °C, respectively. Collectively, our results show that methanol-dependent methanogenesis was operating in anoxic rice field soil but contributed only marginally to total CH₄ production and the isotope effect observed at both low and high temperature.