Evaluation of Three Electron-Donor Permeable Reactive Barrier Materials for Enhanced Reductive Dechlorination of Trichloroethene

Understanding the fate of complex electron-donor materials is important for developing efficient biostimulation strategies to treat ground water contamination by chlorinated ethenes (CEs). The fermentation product distributions and H₂ production of common permeable reactive barrier (PRB) carbon substrates (dairy whey, sodium lactate syrup, and Hydrogen Release Compound [HRC]) were monitored as measures of substrate efficiency in aquifer microcosms spiked with trichloroethene (TCE). In long-term experiments, the fermentation of PRB substrates to slow-degrading organic acids maintained low H₂ partial pressures (≤ 10^?3.5) that, as previous studies suggest, may give competitive advantage to dechlorinators over hydrogenotrophic methanogens. Whey-amended and lactate-amended microcosms exhibited faster complete dechlorination and, according to organic acid carbon flow, higher rates of fermentation to acetate. In HRC-amended microcosms, propionate appeared to serve as a carbon sink that prolonged dechlorination. Upon complete dechlorination, whey microcosms contained the highest percentage of organic acid carbon. Native Dehalococcoides populations increased by 3 orders of magnitude (per g sediment) in whey-amended microcosms. Whey's efficiency improved in microcosms prepared with aquifer sediment and water from within a downgradient whey PRB. Results suggested whey loading values of 0.2 kg/m³ may be appropriate under sufficiently reducing conditions to efficiently stimulate hydrogenotrophic and potentially actetotrophic dechlorinating populations. Renewal of whey PRBs may, however, be required. Implications for further long-term study of cost-efficiencies are discussed.