Patterns of herbivory on Passiflora leaf tissues and species by generalized and specialized feeding insects

Abstract.

• 1 The feeding patterns of specialized (Heliconius butterflies) and generalized (the grasshopper, Osmilia flavolineata) herbivores on leaf age classes and species of neotropical vines in the genus Passiflora are compared by offering them leaf discs in choice experiments.
• 2 Heliconius larvae selected young meristematic leaves over medium aged and mature leaves of Passiflora auriculata on which to feed.
• 3 Adults of O. flavolineata consumed more young leaves of P. pittieri from an array of different ages of leaf tissue, but showed no preference for young over mature leaves of P. tetrastylus or P. data.
• 4 In choice tests conducted with medium aged leaves of four species of Passiflora, O. flavolineata selected P. tetrastylus over P. pittieri and P. vitifolia, which were consumed more than P. alata.
• 5 P. alata, which was avoided by O. flavolineata in feeding trials, was the only abundant Passiflora in neotropical habitats where generalized herbivores (grasshoppers and katydids) were common.
• 6 Our results suggest that Passiflora species in forest habitats where some generalized herbivores are rare have fewer chemical defences, but retain physical defences (tough leaves and hooked trichomes) rendering them unpalatable to specialized herbivores like the larvae of Heliconius butterflies.