Quality Control of Photosystem II: THYLAKOID UNSTACKING IS NECESSARY TO AVOID FURTHER DAMAGE TO THE D1 PROTEIN AND TO FACILITATE D1 DEGRADATION UNDER LIGHT STRESS IN SPINACH THYLAKOIDS*

Photosystem II is vulnerable to light damage. The reaction center-binding D1 protein is impaired during excessive illumination and is degraded and removed from photosystem II. Using isolated spinach thylakoids, we investigated the relationship between light-induced unstacking of thylakoids and damage to the D1 protein. Under light stress, thylakoids were expected to become unstacked so that the photodamaged photosystem II complexes in the grana and the proteases could move on the thylakoids for repair. Excessive light induced irreversible unstacking of thylakoids. By comparing the effects of light stress on stacked and unstacked thylakoids, photoinhibition of photosystem II was found to be more prominent in stacked thylakoids than in unstacked thylakoids. In accordance with this finding, EPR spin trapping measurements demonstrated higher production of hydroxyl radicals in stacked thylakoids than in unstacked thylakoids. We propose that unstacking of thylakoids has a crucial role in avoiding further damage to the D1 protein and facilitating degradation of the photodamaged D1 protein under light stress.In the chloroplasts of higher plants and green algae, thylakoid membranes are closely associated and stack to form grana. Under electron microscopy, cylindrical grana consisting of 10–20 layers of thylakoids have been observed. They have a diameter of 300–600 nm and are interconnected by lamellae of several hundred nm in length (1, 2). The structure of grana in the chloroplasts of higher plants is well known, but the precise role of grana is incompletely understood. Their possible functions in primary photochemical reactions and subsequent events have been discussed extensively (3–9). Photosystem I (PSI)³ and II (PSII) complexes are segregated from each other in thylakoids, showing lateral heterogeneity in their distribution. The PSII complex is a multisubunit pigment-protein complex responsible for the photochemical oxidation of water and reduction of plastoquinone (8, 10–13). It comprises >25 protein subunits and other low molecular weight cofactors, including chlorophylls, carotenoids, plastoquinones, and manganeses. In the chloroplasts of higher plants, PSII complexes and the associated light-harvesting antenna complex LHCII are not present throughout the thylakoid membranes but are abundant in the grana (2, 14). A densely packed array of PSII complexes in the grana was visualized by electron microscopy (8, 15). Grana formation is more prominent in shade leaves (or shade plants) than in sun leaves (or sun plants), so it has been suggested that enrichment of the PSII·LHCII complex in grana is a strategy of plants to collect excitation energy by PSII under weak light (16). The grana structure probably provides an organized environment for PSII. PSI and ATP synthase are located exclusively in the stroma-exposed thylakoids, including the stroma thylakoids, grana end membranes, and grana margins, because these complexes protrude into the stroma. Cytochrome b₆/f complexes without this protrusion are present uniformly throughout the thylakoids (3). It has been suggested that separation of PSI and PSII complexes on the thylakoids through grana formation is important to prevent “spillover” of excitation energy from PSII to PSI, which lowers photosynthesis efficiency (17).An active PSII complex comprises a homodimer of PSII monomers (13). When thylakoids are exposed to excessive visible light, the PSII dimer dissociates into two monomers (18), but the most significant change takes place inside the monomeric PSII, where the reaction center-binding D1 protein is photodamaged and degraded by specific proteases (19, 20). The photodamage to the D1 protein is a photooxidative process. This is caused by reactive oxygen species (ROS), most probably singlet oxygen (¹O₂) or the hydroxyl radical (HO^?) produced by overreduction of the acceptor side of PSII under excessive illumination or by endogenous cationic radicals, such as the oxidized forms of the primary electron donor P680 and the secondary electron donor Tyr_Z (Tyr¹⁶¹ of D1) to PSII (21). Strong illumination of the grana may readily cause damage to the PSII complexes by ROS and endogenous cationic radicals, because the grana is rich in PSII complexes. Segregation of PSI and PSII in the stacked thylakoids should make the electron transport between PSI and PSII a rate-limiting step in the electron flow, and overexcitation of PSII under these conditions may stimulate ROS production at the acceptor side of PSII. Close association of LHCII with the PSII core complexes should also stimulate ROS generation in the grana. Unstacking of the thylakoids, which is also expected to lead to random distribution of PSI and PSII on the thylakoids and dissociation of the LHCII from the PSII core, may be important to avoid photodamage to PSII.In the proteolysis of the damaged D1 protein in the chloroplasts of higher plants, the N-terminal Thr of the D1 protein is dephosphorylated, and the subsequent degradation produces 23- and 9-kDa fragments as the primary cleavage products (19, 20). The protease(s) and phosphatase(s) involved in these steps are presumably localized in the stroma thylakoids, grana end membranes, and grana margin. Lateral migration of the damaged PSII complexes from the grana to the membrane regions where the damaged PSII complexes are repaired is therefore important for degradation of the D1 protein. Thylakoid unstacking, if it occurs under light stress, should stimulate diffusion of the protein complexes on the thylakoids, thereby stimulating D1 turnover.First, we examined if excessive visible light can induce unstacking of the thylakoids. Second, we studied the effects of strong illumination on stacked and unstacked thylakoids to see if they showed different responses to excessive light. We strongly suggest that unstacking of the thylakoids caused by light stress is necessary to avoid further photodamage to the D1 protein and to facilitate degradation and removal of the photodamaged D1 protein from PSII complexes.