Activation of Cu,Zn-Superoxide Dismutase in the Absence of Oxygen and the Copper Chaperone CCS

Eukaryotic Cu,Zn-superoxide dismutases (SOD1s) are generally thought to acquire the essential copper cofactor and intramolecular disulfide bond through the action of the CCS copper chaperone. However, several metazoan SOD1s have been shown to acquire activity in vivo in the absence of CCS, and the Cu,Zn-SOD from Caenorhabditis elegans has evolved complete independence from CCS. To investigate SOD1 activation in the absence of CCS, we compared and contrasted the CCS-independent activation of C. elegans and human SOD1 to the strict CCS-dependent activation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae SOD1. Using a yeast expression system, both pathways were seen to acquire copper derived from cell surface transporters and compete for the same intracellular pool of copper. Like CCS, CCS-independent activation occurs rapidly with a preexisting pool of apo-SOD1 without the need for new protein synthesis. The two pathways, however, strongly diverge when assayed for the SOD1 disulfide. SOD1 molecules that are activated without CCS exhibit disulfide oxidation in vivo without oxygen and under copper-depleted conditions. The strict requirement for copper, oxygen, and CCS in disulfide bond oxidation appears exclusive to yeast SOD1, and we find that a unique proline at position 144 in yeast SOD1 is responsible for this disulfide effect. CCS-dependent and -independent pathways also exhibit differential requirements for molecular oxygen. CCS activation of SOD1 requires oxygen, whereas the CCS-independent pathway is able to activate SOD1s even under anaerobic conditions. In this manner, Cu,Zn-SOD from metazoans may retain activity over a wide range of physiological oxygen tensions.Oxygen is essential for aerobic respiration, but reactive byproducts of oxygen metabolism, such as the superoxide anion, can damage cellular molecules, including proteins, DNA, and lipids (1–3). SOD1s (copper- and zinc-containing superoxide dismutases) provide the primary defense against superoxide damage by catalytically removing it through a disproportionation reaction (4). This reaction involves redox cycling at the copper active site (5). SOD1s require several post-translational modifications to form an active molecule. Copper and zinc are bound by the enzyme, and an intramolecular disulfide bond is formed between two conserved cysteine residues. Although the zinc ion and disulfide bond are not directly involved in the disproportionation reaction, these modifications are required for proper stability and formation of the active site (6–10). The presence of an intramolecular disulfide bond is intriguing, given the fact that the cytosol favors reduced thiols.The activity of SOD1s in vivo is largely controlled through the aforementioned post-translational modifications. Most of what is currently known about activation of SOD1 in vivo has emerged through studies of the bakers'' yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae SOD1. Here insertion of the catalytic copper requires the action of the copper chaperone for SOD³ (CCS) (11). CCS physically interacts with SOD1 to deliver the copper ion and catalyze the disulfide bond formation in an oxygen-dependent manner (12–15). In fact, S. cerevisiae SOD1 (ySOD1) is completely dependent on CCS for insertion of the catalytic copper and oxidation of the disulfide bond (11, 15, 16).Although ySOD1 is dependent on CCS for activity, other eukaryotic SOD1s are not. Mouse and human SOD1 (hSOD1), when expressed in CCS^−/− mouse fibroblasts and in ccs1Δ yeast, still retain some SOD1 activity (17–19). Moreover, the genome for the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans does not contain a CCS-like gene, yet harbors several Cu,Zn-SODs. Previous studies with C. elegans SOD-1 (wSOD-1) have shown that this SOD is activated completely independently of CCS (20). Together, these studies present a strong case for a second SOD1 activation mechanism independent of CCS.There must be inherent differences in SOD1 sequences that dictate whether the enzyme uses CCS or the CCS-independent pathway or both. Through targeted mutagenesis, sequences near the C terminus have been previously identified as being important (19). Yeast SOD1 contains dual prolines at positions 142 and 144, which when mutated in combination allow for CCS-independent activation. Conversely, hSOD1 and wSOD-1 contain non-proline residues at these positions, and if dual prolines are introduced, then CSS-independent activation is blocked (19, 20). How this pair of prolines influences SOD1 activation is not understood.It is interesting that nature has developed two activation mechanisms for such a key enzyme in oxidative stress protection, and these are not likely to be redundant. It was previously predicted that the two pathways draw upon distinct sources of copper (19), since the addition of the catalytic copper ion is limiting for enzyme activation. However, since disulfide oxidation is also limiting for enzyme activity, it is possible that the two pathways diverge at this level. In the current study, we investigate the requirements and regulation of the CCS-dependent and -independent SOD1 activation pathways. Our results strongly indicate that the two pathways do not diverge at the level of upstream copper transporter sources or the kinetics of copper incorporation into SOD1 but rather at the level of disulfide bond formation. Copper is required for CCS-mediated disulfide bond oxidation in yeast SOD1, whereas SOD1s that can be activated without CCS show no such requirement for copper in disulfide oxidation. Moreover, oxygen is required for enzyme activation through CCS, but the CCS-independent pathway is able to bypass the need for molecular oxygen. This allows for significant SOD1 activity to be found at a variety of oxygen concentrations by utilizing two activation pathways.