Evidence from algal bioassays of seasonal nutrient limitations in two English lakes

Comparative laboratory bioassays using Asterionella formosa and Rhodomonas lacustris as test organisms were performed from March to November 1987 on filtered water samples from two English lakes, to assess their potential fertility and to identify possible limiting nutrients. The relative growth responses (log₂ increments) per week, were measured after additions of P, Fe, Si, N, and K singly and in combinations in comparison with unenriched (control) samples. Phosphate appeared to be the major limiting element for both species throughout the year, except during the spring diatom maxima when silicon usually becomes limiting. On most occasions chelated iron increased the growth increments, particularly in combination with phosphate. In general, the bioassay results showed correspondence with the nutrient concentrations in the test waters, which showed low (< 1 µg l^–1) levels of soluble reactive phosphate during all or most of the year and depleted silicon levels in late spring. Comparison between relative (incremental) ratio and absolute (cell concentration) response was made.