Illuminating and mitigating the evolving impacts of COVID-19 on ethnocultural communities: a participatory action mixed-methods study

BACKGROUND:The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated disparities in poverty and illness for people in vulnerable circumstances in ethnocultural communities. We sought to understand the evolving impacts of COVID-19 on ethnocultural communities to inform intersectoral advocacy and community action.METHODS:The Illuminate Project used participatory action research, with cultural health brokers as peer researchers, from Sept. 21 to Dec. 31, 2020, in Edmonton, Alberta. Twenty-one peer researchers collected narratives from members of ethnocultural communities and self-interpreted them as they entered the narratives into the SenseMaker platform, a mixed-method data collection tool. The entire research team analyzed real-time, aggregate, quantitative and qualitative data to identify emerging thematic domains, then visualized these domains with social network analysis.RESULTS:Brokers serving diverse communities collected 773 narratives. Identified domains illuminate the evolving and entangled impacts of COVID-19 including the following: COVID-19 prevention and management; care of acute, chronic and serious illnesses other than COVID-19; maternal care; mental health and triggers of past trauma; financial insecurity; impact on children and youth and seniors; and legal concerns. We identified that community social capital and cultural brokering are key assets that facilitate access to formal health and social system supports.INTERPRETATION:The Illuminate Project has illustrated the entangled, systemic issues that result in poor health among vulnerable members of ethnocultural communities, and the exacerbating effects of COVID-19, which also increased barriers to mitigation. Cultural brokering and community social capital are key supports for people during the COVID-19 pandemic. These findings can inform policy to reduce harm and support community resiliency.

Mahatma Gandhi observed that “the true measure of any society can be found in how it treats its most vulnerable members.” Ethnocultural communities, defined by their unique shared characteristics (e.g., cultural traditions, language, country of origin),¹ face greater challenges and have higher rates of poverty and illness than the general Canadian population. Migration results in conditions that affect all social determinants of health and disproportionally affect health outcomes, herein referred to as vulnerable circumstances.^2,3 The emergence of major outbreaks of SARS-CoV-2 infections in ethnocultural communities highlights both the vulnerable circumstances of these communities and the disparities they face in accessing high-quality, culturally appropriate information and support.^4–7 Studies have shown substantial variation in deaths attributed to COVID-19 based on factors such as age, sex, ethnicity, length of time in Canada, income and education.^8–11 However, given the well-known gap in reporting comprehensive COVID-19 data in relation to race and ethnicity, efforts to measure its impact are hampered.^8–12 There is an urgent need to understand the evolving challenges of COVID-19 to inform action and public policy that can mitigate these challenges.To understand evolving situations of complexity and crisis, sensemaking, defined as “a continuous process to establish situational awareness,”¹³ is a crucial undertaking.¹⁴ Using participatory action research,^15–18 we sought to understand the evolving impacts of COVID-19 on ethnocultural communities to inform broader national efforts to migitate the impacts of COVID-19. Particularly, we sought to understand how the challenges of COVID-19 are entangled with contextual factors at multiple levels, how families and communities are leveraging strengths and social capital to adapt, and the role of cultural brokers in managing the crisis.