Foraging information affects the nature of competitive interactions

If animals can learn environmental cues, how might their use of information affect competitive interactions between species? I used shared‐preference isoleg theory to generate four different predictions regarding possible ways information could affect density‐dependent habitat selection. To test these predictions, I conducted field experiments on the foraging behavior of three coexisting species of hummingbirds. I studied black‐chinned (Archilochus alexandri), blue‐throated (Lampornis clemenciae), and magnificent (Eugenes fulgens) hummingbirds at the Southwestern Research Station in the Chiricahua Mts. of Southeastern Arizona, USA. Blue‐throated hummingbirds behaviorally dominate the other two species. I found that birds foraging with complete information (via learned color cues) avoid some of the negative effects from competition. Birds that foraged with complete information remained highly selective on rich feeders even with high competitor densities. When birds suffered an information deficit, however, the two subordinate species shifted their foraging preferences. The dominant species did not shift preference. Each subordinate's shift reflects its unique place in this competitively structured guild. With high competitor densities, black‐chinneds shifted from selective to opportunistic foraging when they also suffered from an information deficit. Thus, an information deficit caused black‐chinneds to cross over their first isoleg. Rather than reduce foraging efficiency, the magnificents shortened their foraging time. I use the magnificents’ response to competition and an information deficit to explore the possibility that this guild of hummingbirds is centrifugally organized. My results require us to consider the information‐gathering (e.g., learning) abilities of individual decision‐makers when we evaluate density‐dependent habitat selection. Differences in the level of usable information can alter the way coexisting species respond to competitive interactions that potentially structure communities.