Intraspecific variation in samara morphology and flight behavior in acer saccharinum (Aceraceae)

We studied intraspecific variation in samara morphology and flight behavior within and among parent trees of Acer saccharinum (silver maple), with a particular focus on the effect of samara shape. Samara mass, area, wing loading, and descent rate from a 4.5-m indoor balcony were measured for 50 undamaged mature samaras from each of six parents. We found significant differences among parental types for all morphological variables and descent rate. These differences yielded a 50% range in mean dispersal potential among the six parents. There was a strong linear correlation between descent rate and square root of wing loading when mean values were plotted for each of the six parental types. But there was considerable within-parent variation for all measured variables, including substantial nonallometric variation in wing loading caused in part by poor correlations between wing area and fruit weight. Parents also differed widely in the relationship between square root of wing loading and descent rate (linear r² = 0.150-0.788), with one parental type showing no significant relationship. Fruits from the same parent with similar values of the square root of wing loading showed as much as a 75-100% difference in descent rate. The usefulness of mass : area indices such as wing loading is limited by its exclusion of aerodynamically important factors such as mass distribution and wing shape, which in our case caused the six parents to behave aerodynamically almost as if they were six separate species.