The comparative specificity of the inner and outer substrate transfer sites in the choline carrier of human erythrocytes

Summary The substrate specificities on the inner and outer surfaces of the cell membrane have been compared by determining the relative affinities, inside and outside, of a series of choline analogs. The results of two different methods were in agreement: (1) the carrier distribution was determined in the presence of a saturating concentration of an equilibrated analog, using N-ethylmaleimide as a probe for the inward-facing carrier; (2) the degree of competition was measured between an equilibrated analog and choline in the external solution. The carrier sites are found to have markedly different specificities: the outer site is more closely complementary to the structure of choline than is the inner, and even a slight enlargement of either the trimethylammonium or hydroxyethyl group gives rise to preferential binding inside. It is also found that a nonpolar binding region, which is adjacent to the outer site, is absent from the inner site. As the transport mechanism involves the exposure of only one site at a time, first on one surface and then the other, it follows that an extensive reorganization of the structure of the substrate site may occur during the carrier-reorientation step, or alternatively that two distinct sites may be present, only one of which is exposed at a time.