Oligomeric Structure of Colicin Ia Channel in Lipid Bilayer Membranes

Colicin Ia is a soluble, harpoon-shaped bacteriocin which translocates across the periplasmic space of sensitive Escherichia coli cell by parasitizing an outer membrane receptor and forms voltage-gated ion channels in the inner membrane. This process leads to cell death, which has been thought to be caused by a single colicin Ia molecule. To directly visualize the three-dimensional structure of the channel, we generated two-dimensional crystals of colicin Ia inserted in lipid-bilayer membranes and determined a ∼17 three-dimensional model by electron crystallography. Supported by velocity sedimentation, chemical cross-linking and single-particle image analysis, the three-dimensional structure is a crown-shaped oligomer enclosing a ∼35 Å-wide extrabilayer vestibule. Our study suggests that lipid insertion instigates a global conformational change in colicin Ia and that more than one molecule participates in the channel architecture with the vestibule, possibly facilitating the known large scale peptide translocation upon channel opening.Colicin Ia is a pore-forming water-soluble bacterial toxin produced by some strains of Escherichia coli to kill other competing bacteria (1, 2). It belongs to a functionally and structurally similar group of proteins that also includes colicins A (3), E1 (4), and N (5). Each of these proteins consist of three domains with distinct properties; the receptor domain (R), which binds a specific outer membrane receptor on the target cell, and the translocation domain (T) at the N terminus, responsible for traversing the outer membrane and the periplasmic space to deliver the channel-forming domain (C) at the C terminus to the bacterial inner membrane. The bundle of 10 α-helices that compose the C domain changes its conformation to form a voltage-gated ion channel in the plasma membrane. Opening of the channel produces an efflux of ions that depletes the cellular energy resources and ultimately leads to cell death.The x-ray structure of full-length, soluble colicin Ia (69 kDa) has been determined (6). The monomeric molecule is mostly α-helical, with the R domain separated from the T and C domains by a pair of unusually long (∼160 Å) α-helices thought possibly to span the periplasmic space during channel formation (6). The C domain is characterized by two hydrophobic helices (VIII and IX; residues Ala-580—Ile-612) that is surrounded by the remaining eight largely amphipathic α-helices. The same structural motif for the C domain is conserved in other members of the colicin family and is also present in the channel-forming domains of diphtheria toxin, exotoxin A, and the Bcl family of pro- and anti-apoptotic proteins (7). This pair of helices, termed the hydrophobic hairpin, is instrumental in driving the initial membrane insertion event (8) that is followed by a series of large scale pH and voltage-dependent conformational changes in the C domain, resulting in the opening of the ion channel in the plasma membrane (9, 10). In the absence of a high resolution membrane-inserted structure of a channel-forming colicin, solid-state NMR (11, 12), streptavidin binding (8) and cross-linking of site-directed cysteine mutants (9) have suggested that the initial membrane-bound intermediate exists as a two-dimensional helical array of the eight amphipathic helices (I-VII and X) spread across the membrane surface, with the hydrophobic helices (VIII and IX) embedded in the bilayer. A recent electron paramagnetic resonance study using preparations of spin-labeled ColA proteoliposomes has supported a similar umbrella model where the eight amphipathic helices reside at the air-water interface for the closed-channel state (13). Biotin-labeled cysteine mutants have also been used to determine how much of the C domain (aside from the hydrophobic hairpin) crosses the plasma membrane (14, 15) for colicin Ia. A large region of the amphipathic sequence (helices II-V; residues Leu-474—Tyr-541) has been found to cross from the cis to the trans side of the membrane in planar lipid bilayer experiments, resulting in a four-transmembrane segment molecule that is thought to form the ion channel.Because the 12–13 residue α-helices of the C domain are well short of the ∼20 residues required to span the plasma membrane, it has been proposed that conformational changes causing helix extension take place during the channel formation process. ¹³C spin diffusion NMR has indicated that whereas the overall secondary structure of the C domain is preserved, most of the helices undergo “opening,” and modulation of the tertiary structure allows for the required extension of the helices to cross the plasma membrane and form the channel (16). The internal structure of the colicin Ia channel has been investigated by examining the effect of different nonelectrolyte molecules on the single-channel conductance in planar lipid bilayer membranes (17). It was determined that the diameter at the cis entrance (equivalent to the outside of the cell) is 18 Å, and the diameter at the trans entrance (inside the membrane) is 10 Å, with a 7 Å diameter constriction located in close proximity to the trans entrance of the channel. More recent studies (18) employing the substituted cysteine accessibility method to determine what residues line the open colicin Ia channel suggest an hourglass-shaped pore with the most constricted part near the cis rather than the trans side, as opposed to the conclusion of Krasilnikov et al. (17). Both studies point to a pore constriction inside the membrane, and as pointed out by Kienker et al. 18), there exist plausible explanations to reconcile some of the differing results. The large diameter of the colicin Ia channel coupled with the studies which indicate that each colicin Ia molecule contributes four transmembrane segments in the membrane integrated state (14) suggests that the ion channel is formed by a multimer of colicin Ia molecules. However, all of the past studies directed at determining the oligomeric state of any of the colicin channels indicate a monomeric structure. The question as to how a four-transmembrane monomeric protein can form an ion channel of sufficient diameter to allow the passage of ions as large as tetraethyl ammonium (19) has remained unanswered.In this work we have subjected colicin Ia incorporated into lipid bilayer membranes to structural and biochemical investigations. We show, based on cross-linking and velocity sedimentation experiments, single-particle analysis of electron micrographs and results from electron crystallographic analysis of two-dimensional crystals of colicin Ia that the protein forms oligomers upon insertion into the bilayer. The suggested architecture of this oligomer based on the ∼17 Å resolution three-dimensional model and the biological implications, are discussed.