The effects of mulching and abandonment on the viability of the perennial grassland species Plantago lanceolata

Abandonment and fragmentation are the primary causes of decline for many light-demanding grassland species in the modern agricultural landscape. In order to maintain a flora rich in such species, design of management practices based upon knowledge of life-history consequences following management shifts is essential. In this study, we investigated the demography of the perennial grassland species Plantago lanceolata for 4 years in one mulched site and two abandoned sites to compare how the two treatments influenced population dynamics. Compared to abandonment, mulching had a small but positive effect on the population growth rate (λ) of P. lanceolata. In both the mulched and the abandoned sites, growth and stasis among the largest plants contributed most strongly to λ, while the contribution of fecundity was negligible in both treatments. λ of P. lanceolata varied more between years than between treatments, most notably because λ values below unity were observed in the abandoned sites in a 1-year period that included a severe winter. The population of the mulched site consisted of larger ramets and had higher clonal growth rates than the populations of the abandoned sites. This explains the apparently higher resilience to unfavorable climatic conditions in the mulched site. We conclude that management by mulching is better than abandonment for the long-term persistence of P. lanceolata. However, due to low recruitment also in the mulched site, even mulching may be insufficient for P. lanceolata to persist over long time periods.