An ericoid shrub plays a dual role in recruiting both pines and their fungal symbionts along primary succession gradients

Relative importance of positive and negative interactions between plant species may change along disturbance and resource gradients. Positive interactions are suggested to prevail in low resource, low productivity (high stress) conditions and negative interactions in high resource availability. A dwarf shrub, mountain crowberry Empetrum nigrum ssp. hermaphroditum, is known to have allelopathic impacts on both Scots pine Pinus sylvestris and its ectomycorrhizal symbionts. We aimed to study if the outcome of Empetrum impacts on Scots pine changes along primary succession gradients on the dune shores of Bothnian Bay, in Finland, where abiotic stress gradually changes to biotic stress along the succession. We found that Empetrum may act as a facilitator despite its allelopathic effects, since the proportion of Scots pine seedlings established in Empetrum patches was higher than in patches without the shrub in early and mid succession stages, whereas patches without Empetrum were preferred in late succession. The amount of mycelial fungal biomass (ergosterol) in the soil in the vicinity of the seedling roots was higher in Empetrum patches than in patches without Empetrum and it increased along the succession gradient. Proportion of pine root tips colonised by suilloid morphotypes with abundant external mycelia and the diversity of ectomycorrhizal morphotypes were higher in mid successional stage in Empetrum patches compared to patches without Empetrum. Our results suggest that in the harsh physical conditions of the dune shore Empetrum facilitates pine seedling establishment in the early and mid stages of succession by providing mechanical and physical shelter whereas in late succession negative interactions (competition and allelopathy) between the shrub and the pine are dominating. To our knowledge we present the first finding that an ericoid mycorrhizal shrub could enhance both the performance of the ectomycorrhizal host tree and the tree's fungal symbionts.