Diverse Bacteria Inhabit Living Hyphae of Phylogenetically Diverse Fungal Endophytes

Both the establishment and outcomes of plant-fungus symbioses can be influenced by abiotic factors, the interplay of fungal and plant genotypes, and additional microbes associated with fungal mycelia. Recently bacterial endosymbionts were documented in soilborne Glomeromycota and Mucoromycotina and in at least one species each of mycorrhizal Basidiomycota and Ascomycota. Here we show for the first time that phylogenetically diverse endohyphal bacteria occur in living hyphae of diverse foliar endophytes, including representatives of four classes of Ascomycota. We examined 414 isolates of endophytic fungi, isolated from photosynthetic tissues of six species of cupressaceous trees in five biogeographic provinces, for endohyphal bacteria using microscopy and molecular techniques. Viable bacteria were observed within living hyphae of endophytic Pezizomycetes, Dothideomycetes, Eurotiomycetes, and Sordariomycetes from all tree species and biotic regions surveyed. A focus on 29 fungus/bacterium associations revealed that bacterial and fungal phylogenies were incongruent with each other and with taxonomic relationships of host plants. Overall, eight families and 15 distinct genotypes of endohyphal bacteria were recovered; most were members of the Proteobacteria, but a small number of Bacillaceae also were found, including one that appears to occur as an endophyte of plants. Frequent loss of bacteria following subculturing suggests a facultative association. Our study recovered distinct lineages of endohyphal bacteria relative to previous studies, is the first to document their occurrence in foliar endophytes representing four of the most species-rich classes of fungi, and highlights for the first time their diversity and phylogenetic relationships with regard both to the endophytes they inhabit and the plants in which these endophyte-bacterium symbiota occur.Traits related to the establishment and outcome of plant-fungus symbioses can reflect not only abiotic conditions and the unique interactions of particular fungal and plant genotypes (49, 50, 56, 59, 62, 67) but also additional microbes that interact intimately with fungal mycelia (4, 12, 42). For example, mycorrhizosphere-associated actinomycetes release volatile compounds that influence spore germination in the arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungus Gigaspora margarita (Glomeromycota) (14). Levy et al. (34) describe Burkholderia spp. that colonize spores and hyphae of the AM fungus Gigaspora decipiens and are associated with decreased spore germination. Diverse “helper” bacteria have been implicated in promoting hyphal growth and the establishment of ectomycorrhizal symbioses (23, 26, 57, 70). Minerdi et al. (43) found that a consortium of ectosymbiotic bacteria limited the ability of the pathogen Fusarium oxysporum to infect and cause vascular wilts in lettuce, with virulence restored to the pathogen when ectosymbionts were removed.In addition to interacting with environmental and ectosymbiotic bacteria, some plant-associated fungi harbor bacteria within their hyphae (first noted as “bacteria-like organisms” of unknown function) (38). These bacteria, best known from living hyphae of several species of the Glomeromycota and Mucoromycotina, can alter fungal interactions with host plants in diverse ways (see references 12, 31, and 51). For example, the vertically transmitted bacterium “Candidatus Glomeribacter gigasporarum” colonizes spores and hyphae of the AM fungus Gigaspora gigasporarum (9, 10). Removal of the bacterial partner from the fungal spores suppresses fungal growth and development, altering the morphology of the fungal cell wall, vacuoles, and lipid bodies (37). In turn, the discovery of phosphate-solubilizing bacteria within Glomus mossae spores (44), coupled with the recovery of a P-transporter operon in Burkholderia sp. from Gigaspora margarita (54), suggests a competitive role in phosphate acquisition and transport by these bacteria within the AM symbiosis. Within the Mucoromycotina, Partida-Martinez and Hertweck (51) reported that a soilborne plant pathogen, Rhizopus microsporus, harbors endosymbiotic Burkholderia that produces a phytotoxin (rhizoxin) responsible for the pathogenicity of the fungus.These examples, coupled with the discovery of bacteria within hyphae of the ectomycorrhizal Dikarya (Tuber borchii; Ascomycota; Laccaria bicolor and Piriformospora indica; Basidiomycota) (5-8, 58), suggest that the capacity to harbor endohyphal bacteria is widespread among fungi. To date, however, endocellular bacteria have been recovered only from fungi that occur in the soil and rhizosphere (12, 31). Here we report for the first time that phylogenetically diverse bacteria occur within living hyphae of foliar endophytic fungi, including members of four classes of filamentous Ascomycota. We use a combination of light and fluorescence microscopy to visualize bacterial infections within living hyphae of representative strains. Then, drawing from surveys of endophytes from asymptomatic foliage of cupressaceous trees in five biogeographic provinces, we provide a first characterization of the phylogenetic relationships, host associations, and geographic distributions of endohyphal bacteria associated with focal fungal endophytes.