Differences in species diversity of Monogenea between the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans

Data from five extensive surveys each in the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans show that relative species diversity (number of parasite species per host species) of gill Monogenea of coastal marine fishes is greater in the northern and southwestern Pacific than in the northeastern and central- and southwestern Atlantic. Relative species diversity is markedly lower in the cold northeastern Atlantic than in the warmer parts of the Atlantic examined, and in the northern Pacific than in the warm southwestern Pacific. The difference between the northern Pacific and Atlantic is entirely or almost entirely due to a much greater number of species of Gyrodactylidae in the northern Pacific. A species-area relationship cannot explain the difference, because the area of the northern Pacific is not larger than that of the northern Atlantic and because Gyrodactylidae are cold-water forms which cannot have immigrated from warmer seas. The difference is tentatively explained by an evolutionary time hypothesis: more species of Gyrodactylidae have accumulated in the much older Pacific than in the Atlantic Ocean. Alternatively, an ecological time hypothesis may explain the difference: ice sheets during the last glaciation covered much more of the continental shelf in the northern Atlantic than in the northern Pacific, possibly extinguishing more Monogenea in the former than in the latter Ocean.