Host range in solitary versus gregarious parasitoids: a laboratory experiment

Behavioural interactions among relatives may have consequences for many other traits. We tested the hypothesis that solitary parasitoids (displaying siblicidal behaviour in their larvae) have narrower host ranges than gregarious parasitoids (with tolerant larvae). In laboratory experiments, we compared parasitization success in two sister species of braconid wasp Aphaereta genevensis (Fischer), solitary, and Aphaereta pallipes (Say), gregarious (Hymenoptera: Braconidae: Alysiini)] on eight Drosophila species or strains. Host species or strain was the most important factor affecting parasitization success, and some of this variation was accountable to host physiological defences. Although two hosts were more suitable for the solitary species, and one more suitable for the gregarious species, these differences were small, and there was no consistent difference across all hosts. Wasp body size was positively correlated with parasitization success in both wasp species. This may be because body size increases oviposition success, or the motivation to oviposit. In A. pallipes parasitization success peaked after 3–4 days, but later in A. genevensis. This is likely due to low life expectancy and high egg loads increasing oviposition tendency in young A. pallipes, and egg limitation decreasing oviposition tendency in old A. pallipes. These data suggest that interactions among wasp larvae do not greatly affect the size of the fundamental niche examined here. However, they show the potential for life history traits, which differ between the species as a likely consequence of larval interactions, to affect the extent of the realized niche.