Interaction of chicken cystatin with inactivated papains.

Papain which was inactivated by covalent attachment of small substituents to the active-site cysteine, up to the size of a carbamoylmethyl group, bound with high affinity to chicken cystatin (Kd less than approximately 15 pM), although less tightly than did active papain (Kd approximately 60 fM). However, as the size of the substituent was increased further, the affinity decreased appreciably, generally in proportion to the size of the inactivating group. For instance the dissociation constants for papain inactivated with N-ethylmaleimide and N-(L-3-trans-carboxyoxiran-2-carbonyl)-L-leucyl]-amido-(4-guanido )butane were 0.17 and approximately 10 microM respectively. The spectroscopic changes accompanying the reaction of all but the most weakly binding (Kd greater than or equal to 2 microM) inactivated papains with cystatin were similar to those induced by the active enzyme. Interactions involving the reactive cysteine residue of papain are thus not crucial for high-affinity binding of the enzyme to cystatin, in accordance with a recently proposed model for the enzyme-inhibitor complex, based on computer docking experiments. In this model there is sufficient space around the reactive cysteine in the complex for a small inactivating group, explaining the tight binding of papains with such substituents. However, larger inactivating groups cannot be accommodated in this space and therefore must displace the inhibitor out of the tight fit with the enzyme, in agreement with the observed decrease in binding affinity with increasing size of bulkier substituents. The kinetics of binding of cystatin to inactivated papains were compatible with simple, reversible, bimolecular reactions, having association rate constants of (7-9) x 10(6) M-1 s-1 at pH 7.4, 25 degrees C, similar to what was shown previously for the binding of cystatin to active papain. The rate of association of the inhibitor with either active or inactivated papain thus appears to be primarily diffusion-controlled. The decreasing affinity of cystatin for papains inactivated with groups of increasing size was shown to be due to progressively higher dissociation rate constants, consistent with the greater impairment of fit between the binding regions of the two molecules.