Fermentative metabolism impedes p53-dependent apoptosis in a Crabtree-positive but not in Crabtree-negative yeast

Tumour cells distinguish from normal cells by fermenting glucose to lactate in presence of sufficient oxygen and functional mitochondria (Warburg effect). Crabtree effect was invoked to explain the biochemical basis of Warburg effect by suggesting that excess glucose suppresses mitochondrial respiration. It is known that the Warburg effect and Crabtree effect are displayed by Saccharomyces cerevisiae, during growth on abundant glucose. Beyond this similarity, it was also demonstrated that expression of human pro-apoptotic proteins in S. cerevisiae such as Bax and p53 caused apoptosis. Here, we demonstrate that p53 expression in S. cerevisiae (Crabtree-positive yeast) causes increase in ROS levels and apoptosis when cells are growing on non-fermentable carbon sources but not on fermentable carbon sources, a feature similar to tumour cells. In contrast, in Kluyveromyces lactis (Crabtree-negative yeast) p53 causes increase in ROS levels and apoptosis regardless of the carbon source. Interestingly, the increased ROS levels and apoptosis are correlated to increased oxygen uptake in both S. cerevisiae and K. lactis. Based on these results, we suggest that at least in yeast, fermentation per se does not prevent the escape from apoptosis. Rather, the Crabtree effect plays a crucial role in determining whether the cells should undergo apoptosis or not.