Efficacy of four semi-selective media for recovery of Xanthomonas campestris pv. campestris from tropical soils

R. FUKUI, R. ARIAS AND R. ALVAREZ. 1994. Four semi-selective media, CS20 ABN, aesculin—trehalose (ET), Fieldhouse—Sasser (FS), and starch—methionine (SM), were compared for efficacy in recovering Xanthomonas campestris pv. campestris from artificially and naturally infested soils. Recoveries of X. c. campestris from soils infested with relatively large populations were similar on the four media. The FS and ET media exhibited higher selectivity against background saprophytes, whereas enumeration of X. c. campestris on CS20 ABN or SM was often hampered by the overgrowth of background saprophytes. Among three starch-containing media (CS20 ABN, ET and FS media), the zones of starch hydrolysis, characteristic of colonies of X. c. campestris, were most distinctive for FS medium. This allowed easier identification of the target colonies among numerous non-target colonies in tests with soil containing smaller numbers of X. c. campestris. Although the starch zone was also distinctive on CS20 ABN, this medium was not as effective as FS because the starch zones were so large that neighbouring zones fused with each other and many saprophytes formed colonies within the zones. Overall, FS was most suitable for soil studies in terms of the consistent recovery of the pathogen, the selectivity against saprophytes, and the differentiation from non-target organisms.