c-Cbl is not required for ERK1/2-dependent degradation of BimEL

Bim_EL the most abundant Bim splice variant, is subject to ERK1/2-catalysed phosphorylation, which targets it for ubiquitination and proteasome-dependent destruction. In contrast, inactivation of ERK1/2, following withdrawal of survival factors, promotes stabilization of Bim_EL. It has been proposed that the RING finger protein Cbl binds to Bim_EL and serves as its E3 ubiquitin ligase. However, this is controversial since most Cbl substrates are tyrosine phosphoproteins and yet Bim_EL is targeted for destruction by ERK1/2-catalysed serine phosphorylation. Consequently, a role for Cbl could suggest a second pathway for Bim_EL turnover, regulated by direct tyrosine phosphorylation, or could suggest that Bim_EL is a coincidence detector, requiring phosphorylation by ERK1/2 and a tyrosine kinase. Here we show that degradation of Bim_EL does not involve its tyrosine phosphorylation; indeed, Bim_EL is not a tyrosine phosphoprotein. Furthermore, Bim_EL fails to interact with Cbl and growth factor-stimulated, ERK1/2-dependent Bim_EL turnover proceeds normally in Cbl-containing or Cbl−/− fibroblasts. These results indicate that Cbl is not required for ERK1/2-dependent Bim_EL turnover in fibroblasts and epithelial cells and any role it has in other cell types is likely to be indirect.